Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


You've been shamed – Google cuts images after privacy outcry

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 21 March 2009
GOOGLE removed scores of images from its new UK Street View service yesterday, a day after its launch.
The service offers a virtual tour of streets in 25 UK cities including Edinburgh, Glasgow. Aberdeen and Dundee.

But concerns about the software used to blur faces and car number plates led to dozens of areas being blanked out after complaints from the public.

A Google spokeswoman confirmed that the company had received a number of objections.

"We cannot give out numbers for the complaints, but we are dealing with them and blacking out the images within hours.

"We know the service is not perfect, but we are relying on users to tell us where there are problems. We are happy to remove any images that people are not happy with."

Yesterday images of Lothian and Borders Police Headquarters in Fettes Avenue, Edinburgh, and of Queen Street and Great King Street in the capital were replaced by a blank screen and the words: "This image is no longer available."

Lothian and Borders Police said it took matters of security extremely seriously. "If any incidents arise that may compromise the security of an individual or organisation, we will act accordingly," a spokesman said.

A picture of a man emerging from a London sex shop and one of a man vomiting in the street were removed after complaints.

Google said the service had proved widely popular, with thousands of people logging on. The company believes the service will be used by people wishing to view property or to check images of hotels, tourist destinations and holiday apartments.

But it emerged yesterday that some of the capital's most famous streets – Princes Street, Cockburn Street and George Street – are completely missing from the service.

In Glasgow, Buchanan Street and other pedestrianised areas were unavailable.

A Google spokeswoman said the specially-adapted camera car was unable to supply photographs of some areas because of roadworks, one-way systems and access difficulties.

Independent MSP Margo MacDonald said: "There's something wrong there. I'm intrigued by why they can't take pictures of Princes Street – if they can't find a way to photograph it there is something wrong. On the other hand, the way things are just now I would pay them not to take photographs of Princes Street or George Street."

Dr John Welford, Edinburgh spokesman for the privacy campaigners No2ID, said the group did not object to street photographs in principle, but he said: "I think there is a huge invasion of privacy going on in incremental ways. The problem is the function creep – people's acceptance of these things and feeling you can't do anything about it.

"I would like a government which would believe in privacy and not allow this invasion of privacy to get out of hand."

The Information Comissioner's Office said it would look into suggestions that Google had not done enough to ensure that faces and number plates were concealed.


Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 20 March 2009 9:54 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Google
 
1

Fifi la Bonbon,

21/03/2009 01:04:47
"Independent MSP Margo MacDonald said ..."

Really, it doesn't matter what she said. Her opinion on this matter can surely be of no interest to anyone but herself and whichever person is responsible for her publicity arrangements.
2

JulesF,

Kirkliston 21/03/2009 04:36:14
Margo :

A Google spokeswoman said the specially-adapted camera car was unable to supply photographs of some areas because of roadworks, one-way systems and access difficulties.

It's a sophisticated piece of technology mounted within a car. If it can't be driven up a street it can't provide photographs. It's not a hack of a journalist with a digital camera !
3

,

21/03/2009 06:18:22
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Road to the isles,

21/03/2009 08:49:03
#3

L&B take matters of security very seriously so yer no allowed to look at their HQ.
5

Tartan Viking,

21/03/2009 10:52:29
Terrorist dream this Google lark.
6

SandyBottoms,

Edinburgh 21/03/2009 12:32:09
"The Information Comissioner's Office said it would look into suggestions that Google had not done enough to ensure that faces and number plates were concealed."

Yes, because only the government can have this information.

Hypocrites.
7

glaswegian at heart,

florida 21/03/2009 17:26:40
I found the google street map site by accident .I thought of privacy or the lack thereof but I must admit it did my heart good to be able to see my sister's house right down to her window curtains.I haven't seen my sister in 9 years and may never see her again as I'm unable to travel.We do talk on the phone but the the street site was a pleasant experience .
8

mobocaster,

Aberdeen 23/03/2009 11:32:39
Well, you can read my numberplate on it but unless someone wants to match it up with another identical vehicle or something, I don't see what more you can do with it.

One of my elderly neighbours can also be seen coming back from the paper shop, so I can probably make a good guess at what time of day they drove down my road too.
9

Douglas,

Bathgate 27/03/2009 23:44:29
Lothian and Borders Police said it took matters of security extremely seriously.
It was especially keen for members of the public to look away when a person in a uniform bedecked with baubles and topped off with a fluorescent jacket walked past lest the wearer be identified as upholder of the rule of law (kiddin' on likes).
10

Yankee girl,

California 28/03/2009 04:43:23
I was just using the street view yesterday to scope out some hotels and neighborhoods in Portland, Oregon for an upcoming trip. Even though I'm not too sure about some of the neighborhoods, I didn't see anyone coming out of a sex shop or vomiting so they must be ok. ;)

Anyway, I think this is a handy tool and I'm quite impressed with it. Now I can feel reasonably confortable about areas in advance.

Too bad about some of the Scotland pics being unavailable, though. Here's to getting your roadwork done soon so the camera car can get through.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.