Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


GPs may close doors to new patients in protest at pay freeze

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 April 2007
FAMILY doctors in Scotland could start closing their doors to new patients in the coming months, GPs will warn today.
A pay freeze for GPs has been condemned by the profession, whose members say morale is heading towards a new low.

Today, a British Medical Association (BMA) conference in Clydebank will hear that GPs are considering whether they can keep taking o
n new patients with no extra money.

They say the freeze set by the government effectively means a 6 per cent cut in pay.

Last month, Gordon Brown, the Chancellor, unveiled below-inflation pay rises for health staff, including zero for GPs.

Andy Kerr, the Scottish health minister, insisted the pay awards struck "a balance between fairness and discipline in the fight against inflation".

But Dr Dean Marshall, chairman of the BMA's Scottish GPs committee, said GP practices were now being put under considerable financial pressure.

"GPs are individual contractors to the NHS and their businesses work on profit and loss. This pay freeze is essentially a 6 per cent loss to us," he said.

The new contract allowed GPs to opt out of providing out-of-hours cover, as well as introducing financial incentives for good practice, which have pushed the pay of many above the £100,000 mark. But Dr Marshall said this good work was now being undone.

While it had not happened yet, GPs might soon have to stop taking on patients.

"Most GPs don't want to do that because they care for their patients," he said. "But in the next few months, once GPs have put their business plans together, we could see GPs closing their lists because it does not make financial sense to keep taking on more patients."

Margaret Watt, the chairwoman of the Scottish Patients' Association, claimed GPs were "blackmailing" patients. "They are holding us to ransom by saying they will close their lists. It is obscene," she said.

Shona Robison, for the SNP, said the new GP contract had been substantially resourced and services should be expanding, not reducing. "I think the view of the public is that GPs have got a good deal and we need to make sure they are delivering on that," she said.

A Labour spokeswoman said the party valued the work that GPs and other staff did and they had been rewarded.

• The Department of Health apologised yesterday after a security lapse in the government's controversial application website for junior doctors revealed personal details about applicants, including addresses, telephone numbers, convictions, sexual orientation and religion, for several hours.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 April 2007 11:39 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: General practitioners
 
1

somerferg,

oz 26/04/2007 01:25:25

Now being held to ransom by geedy GPs. Personally I think they just want some extra time off to go golfing!

2

Peter Cherbi,

Edinburgh 26/04/2007 02:46:00

surely this cant be allowed to happen, after the shambles with the dentists

3

Anne,

26/04/2007 05:45:55

Take a look at that postscript - this is the set of clowns who think that uploading all our medical records for access by 250,000 "authorised" personnel would be a good idea.
They can't even secure the details of F1 applicants! .
God help us all.

4

Al,

26/04/2007 11:28:40

GPs are on the lowest rung of the ladder when it comes to doctors' pay but that is because they are far less qualified than other medics. The government made a mistake in giving them too much in the last pay deal and now has to claw some back. Despite this pay freeze, they are still very well paid for what they do.

5

Keke,

Aberdeenshire 26/04/2007 11:43:51

The 'caring' side of the NHS ... you lot can suffer because we want more money. Bloody mercenaries.

6

john montgomery,

26/04/2007 12:05:52

The new contracts for GP's three years ago gave the doctors a whacking
50% pay increase and allowed them to opt out of out of hours service.
It also meant those doctors who wished to provide such services were
being given huge increases in pay for such work. In fact, one GP in
Scotland made over £300,000 due to providing out of hours cover.
Admittedly, this was not the norm. On top of this over the past two
years, the amount GP's have been taking from their practice profits (
yes it is a business now!) has increased from 42% to 45%.

All of this has put a strain on NHS finances to the tune nationwide of
an extra £100's of millions of pounds a year which was not foreseen
when the new contracts were negotiated. I would posit the BMA knew
what they were doing when they met the Government. Dr Andrew Fradd
one of their chief negotiators is quoted as saying they could not
believe what they were being offered. Far from thinking about the
consequences, of course the BMA grabbed what they could. The scenario
was more for less, that saw no need for our of hours work, and no
Saturday surgeries, for example. Now, recently, the head the GP's in
Scotland is shouting about doctors not being given a pay increase in
the recent round of NHS negotiations. Is over £100,000 plus a year not
enough.

I get a good service from my GP but I wonder are they not having
somewhat of a PR disaster now with this debacle.

7

Hospitalphoenix,

26/04/2007 15:39:17

GPs do an excellent job, but they got such a good pay rise with the new deal that IMO they should be happy with a pay freeze.

Sure, it was the government who got it wrong (it wasn't the GPs being greedy, much as doctor bashers like to promote this idea!) but with the current proposals they *are* making themselves look like a greedy bunch.

None of us went into medicine wanting to get rich. If anyone did, they made a grave mistake. We should do it as a vocation and be rewarded appropriately. £100,000 for being a GP is excessive. They should be ahppy with it, and not demanding more payrises

COI - doctor but not a GP

8

GP,

26/04/2007 17:42:57

The GP system is out of date and out of touch with reality.
Scrap the GP system completely as it is a massive burden on the NHS.
Create town clinics with real doctors doing real work not peddling drugs and sick notes.

Clinics that provide preventative medicine via scheduled appointments and a very small emergency appointment facility.

The vast majority of GP's time is wasted on hypochondriacs and lazy good for nothings.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.