Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Tram works edge toward late finish

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 June 2009
SHOPPERS in Edinburgh's Princes Street may glance across the closed-off roadway to find it deserted apart from red and white barriers, portable buildings and works vans.
But behind the fences and along a 11-mile swathe of the city, the Scottish capital's tram line is taking shape, in a project involving more than 700 workers.

The project, which officials describe as on a par with the Forth Bridge and the most com
plex project in Scotland for a generation, has been beset by problems and delays – the latest being the construction company admitting for the first time a key piece of work is behind schedule.

The agency behind the tram project, Transport Initiatives Edinburgh (TIE), said the tram depot at Gogar, near Edinburgh airport, could be up to nine months late.

The company was forced to admit the delay after questions were lodged under Freedom of Information legislation.

The fresh delay comes on top of new TIE chief executive Richard Jeffrey's recent admission that the project might not be finished by July 2011 and could run into 2012.

However, for now, across the city centre are the first tangible signs of the impending return of trams to Edinburgh after nearly 53 years.

Passengers on the main Edinburgh-Glasgow railway line are also seeing evidence of the £545 million scheme taking shape over the largely off-street half of the route, west of Haymarket, where bridges and earthworks are visible.

A viaduct is under construction beside Haymarket station to bring the tram line from road to rail level, but building has been delayed by prolonged work to trace an unrelated gas leak and the redesign of a retaining wall following the demolition of the Caley Alehouse.

Further west, diggers are preparing the route beside Carrick Knowe golf course, while there is foundation work on a new bridge and preliminary work on the former guided busway in Stenhouse.

Just west of Edinburgh Park station, a seven-span viaduct over the railway line is on schedule for completion in September or October.

North of the Gyle, an underpass taking trams under the A8 is being built, which will see a 70ft new section of the road running over its roof. Traffic diversions will continue until the structure is complete next year.

To the north of the adjacent Gogar roundabout, foundations are about to be laid in a huge water-filled hole that will become the tram depot.

Work has already been delayed by "challenges" such as the relocation of major gas and water pipes, along with sewers, which were not originally included. The setbacks mean there is now a race against time to get the depot ready before the first trams arrive from Spain for testing in April or May next year. Test runs on a one-mile section of the route to Ingliston would follow later in 2010.

Tram project director Stephen Bell told The Scotsman: "I would expect the depot to be able to house the first tram at that time. It will not be finished, but we will be able to start testing."

However, he said the precise timescale for the work – and the rest of the project – had still to be agreed with the construction consortium following resolution of a dispute over work in Princes Street in February.

Back in the city centre, drivers have already had their patience tested for two years, as essential preliminary work to divert a complex web of underground pipes and cables continues.

The good news is that the work is nearing completion, with 80 per cent done and the remainder due to be finished by September – nine months late – other than at Edinburgh airport and near Leith docks. Six sites are still being worked on, at Haymarket, Shandwick Place, the Mound, St Andrew Square, Leith Walk and Constitution Street in Leith.

However, the bad news is that tram-line construction could bring the worst traffic disruption yet when work starts in Picardy Place next year for up to 12 months. The crucial roundabout at the top of Leith Walk will become an enlarged circular one-way system.

Mr Bell admitted the site would be "the hardest place to deal with" because of its location, and detailed discussions are under way with the police and Lothian Buses in an attempt to minimise the impact.

He said: "It is the area which will see the greatest changes to traffic, and one of the hardest for us to see a straightforward solution. However, we will make sure we get it right in the way that we have got Princes Street right." Details are due in August.

The west end of Princes Street saw the first tram tracks being laid earlier this month, with the work – currently running one month late – continuing east as far as Waverley Bridge by the autumn. Track laying is also due to get under way in Shandwick Place and on the former guided busway in August, and on Leith Walk in September.

EDINBURGH TRAM ROUTE

Gogar depot

THE 14-acre site – about the size of Murrayfield stadium – will house the 27-strong tram fleet. Foundation work is about to start. However, delays caused by pipe diversion work will mean the complex will be only partially finished when the first tram arrives there for testing next April or May.

Murrayfield

A HUGE new embankment, up to 13ft high and stretching from Roseburn Street to Balgreen Road, will carry the tram line past Murrayfield stadium and above homes in Baird Drive. Alterations to the Murrayfield Wanderers' clubhouse and repositioning of some stadium turnstiles will be required.

Princes Street

TRACKS started being laid earlier this month between South Charlotte Street and Castle Street, and will extend east to Frederick Street by next month. The work will continue over the Mound junction, where a 120-year-old cast-iron gas main has been replaced. The work is to finish in November.

Picardy Place

TRAM-LINE construction in Picardy Place could cause the greatest disruption of the whole project because of its location on the city's traffic network. Work will not start till next year after Princes Street has reopened because of a cap on the number of city centre road closures at one time.

Leith Walk

TRADERS and residents in Leith Walk who have endured two years of roadworks while pipes and cables are moved have been promised a respite in August – but disruption will resume in September when tram-line construction gets under way. The diversion work should be finished next month.

Trams

TRAM body shells are taking shape at manufacturer CAF's factory in Spain and the first test-track trials are due later this year. The first tram is due to arrive in Edinburgh next April or May, for test runs.

Five of the 27 trams should be delivered by next summer and the rest by mid-2011





Page 1 of 1

 
1

,

22/06/2009 00:32:26
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

For Scotlands Future,

Vote for the SNP 22/06/2009 00:43:41
I see the Scotsman is on a PR exercise with it's articles today.

Have they solved the problem of the trams turning from York place up into St Andrews Sq. I understood that the turn and gradient combined were too much for the trams??

I suggested they should lower St Andrews Sq, but nobody listened.
3

Charles Linskaill,

Tram's!,..A Personal View!! 22/06/2009 00:53:39

Well!, Yesterday I was out soaking up the sun, with my EsDYW, walking in Princes Street in Edinburgh, you will have noticed straight away, the I did not say "walking along Princes Street, the reason being, You Cant Anymore, and for some time now "walk-along", in the heart of Edinburgh!
Princes Street, now renamed Battle Street, as it is a 'Battle', to walk 10yards without a 'Fight'!
People struggling to get past all the Tram-Work-Barriers', massive holes in the road, I wonder if they found anything interesting, like 'buried treasure' :)
One thing that has not changed, is the two, not soo Scottish Shops, selling their 'tad', and yes!, the Stupid Loud Music, being played from a very tiered, ghetto blaster, with worn speakers, and the two manikins outside, that have half a nose and arm, it looked like someone had, beaten them up!
What the Tourists must think!, 'God-only-Knows'

But the Day will Come, when the First Tram will Run!

And we will 'Wonder', What all the 'FUSS_WAS_ABOUT'!

:))

4

Statsman,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 01:47:15
The council can stick the trams up their....
5

Julian.,

edinburgh 22/06/2009 02:01:58
#2

It's just as well nobody listened.

I think I've spotted a reason why the Gogar depot is nine months behind schedule; I hardly ever see anyone working on it when I drive past.
6

Brianwci,

22/06/2009 02:19:58
We'll all love them once they're here. I know I will.

I know that's a bit 'off message' for an old Nat like myself but I think the party will survive.
7

,

22/06/2009 02:39:48
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
8

Charles Linskaill,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 03:35:43

~6 Brianwci,

I recon that if we do not all do, our Children, and our Children's Children, will take our Trams, like a,..
...'Pea_in_a_Pod',,and furthermore Appreciate our Trams!

9

RonsOpinion,

Edinburgh & Shanhai 22/06/2009 04:47:06
A this moment I am in Shanghai and maybe it is unrealistic to make any comparisons between a city that has four times the population than the whole of Scotland but when you compare how dynamic and forward looking this city is with the total lack of any sensible infrastructure investment in Edinburgh since, well, the Victorians, we should be less critical and more supportive of even the small step of reintroducing trams to our city again.

I think some of the moaners should get real and see how far Edinburgh has fallen behind other cities in the world when it comes to transportation.
10

Mallory,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 05:39:05
Is it true that TIE have had to rent rather than purchase a key part of the land required for the Trams?
11

,

22/06/2009 05:55:32
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
12

Sioux Man Chu,

22/06/2009 07:15:19
As if one Linskaill isn't one too many!
13

eric,

lothian 22/06/2009 08:09:08
I see that Hamleys of london will open.... in Glasgow.At St enoch next to subway station,
14

Gdgy,

22/06/2009 08:20:40
The signs on the A90 bridge road entering Edinburgh state "Princes Street Works" ....funny that......
15

Jambo-ree,

22/06/2009 08:32:15
Excuse me? "To the north of the adjacent Gogar roundabout, foundations are about to be laid in a huge water-filled hole that will become the tram depot."

They're building in a huge water filled hole at a time when the Met Office is predicting heavier rainfall over the next decade or so? I suppose they know what they are doing, eh?

All those signs saying "Taking you to the shops in 2011" should have a bit added saying "Taking you to the cleaners now".

No more than a vanity project.

#14 That'll make it easy for the Hamley's staff to get their pieces for lunch then ;o)
16

ddmc,

22/06/2009 08:39:34
How much money will edinburgh council tax payers be reamed for as a result of all the delays ?

17

Linda,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 08:45:56
Unionists forced this tram project on SNP, who realised that the estimated costs were unrealistic, as a means of trying to derail the SNP's budget plans.
18

S'me,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 09:14:14
It'll be good.
19

reincarnated,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 09:34:29
It'll be good if you want to travel to Leith or the Airport.

£500,000,000 + worth of good.
20

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 22/06/2009 10:38:55
18 - rubbish - the esh en pee thought they could win votes . We do not pay politicians to follow the views and prejudices of the great unwashed .
21

paulr,

edinburgh 22/06/2009 11:16:06
Picardy palce will cause the worst yet......

"However, we will make sure we get it right in the way that we have got Princes Street right"

traffic chaos, total disruption of all services, businesses driven to bankruptcy, yeah you got it right!!!!
22

Scary Bear,

22/06/2009 11:22:54
#22 - The trams were voted through by Labour and other parties in the Scottish Parliament. The SNP opposed the trams.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/edinburgh_and_east/6243158.stm

http://news.scotsman.com/edinburghtransportplans/Opposition-parties-in-bid-to.3299192.jp
23

mr broon,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 11:51:15
A search of 'British Trams Online' reveals that with only ONE single exception, trams or light railway projects in England, and now Scotland, have never been completed on time, or within budget.

The one exception being the Docklands Light Railway which is being constructed for the London Olympics in 2012.

However, this project has literally had BILLIONS thrown at it, unlike the tight budgets and time scales elsewhere.
24

Voice of reason,

EDINBURGH 22/06/2009 12:00:30
24 - name me a business in Princes St which has gone bankrupt as a result of the tram project .
25

Green Jock,

22/06/2009 13:24:32
Why all the moaning? As someone`s said we`ve fallen way behind the rest of Europe with our public transport system (lack of high-speed trains particularly)and anything that gets us to leave our cars at home (or better still sell them) has to be given a chance. Hopefully the tram will be a success and network can be extended (including line to a new main train station where highspeed line to London,Paris and Brussels will start).
26

logic says cancel!!!!,

22/06/2009 13:52:04
missed opportunity to move into the future with a rail link that would have linked the airport to the rail network,benefiting all of scotland not just edinburgh.Picture this a small country of 5 million with to main airports linked by rail, linking 80 % of the country together,how many car journeys would that have taken of the roads?What do we get for 600million in comparison?---------the measure of our politician, those visionarys.we have got brown saying "we will be the envy of the world when we all have 50 meg broadband in our houses",(ye right ,clown)we had wheeler saying "we will be the envy of europe with our tram line",These monumental achievements. NOT, one has to laugh.. or cry, ha
27

GraemeH,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 14:06:37
More lies from TIE. Utility diversions were supposed to be completed in Sept last year (note to Scotsman, it's not difficult to check the business plan) - completing them (they hope!) in Sept this year does not make them 9 months late.

Similarly, at Gogar construction of the depot itself was due to start in August last year - given it aint started yet that also looks like a minimum 1 year overdue.

Another massive lie of course is the phrase 700 "workers". Given the utter incompetene of TIE's project management my guess is about 23 workers with the rest smokin cigarettes, chatting on their mobiles, reading newspapers or designing baseball caps for schoolkids.
28

Woody47,

22/06/2009 15:22:11
Why cant they work 24/7 to get the job done? If they are so far behind I would also assume that penalties will be applied as any contract I have been involved in ALAWYS have completion dates and penalties. If there are no penalties then the peolple behind signing the contract on behalf of the people of Edinburgh should be sued for negligence.
29

Leila,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 15:40:41
#28: it's all very well aspiring to reduce car use, but public transport schemes cost a lot of money. The Edinburgh tram project has a finite budget which won't be increased no matter what, it's known to be behind schedule and over budget, it's already been cut back and it's quite likely to be cut back further to stay within the available funds. You just can't talk casually about "giving it a chance". This is public money, not some magic pot of gold. If funds were unlimited then we could talk about future extensions. But the reality is there's no chance.
30

Yonthing!,

22/06/2009 15:54:03
27, Voice of reason:

"name me a business in Princes St which has gone bankrupt as a result of the tram project"

Not a realistic question, since all the shops on Princes Street are part of national or multinational chains.

However there are many independent operations along the rest of the route who have already gone out of business. Tram Stop, the cafe in Haymarket immediately springs to mind, and if I wasn't meant to be working I'm sure I could google for more.
31

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 22/06/2009 15:56:14
What a strange article.

Minor negativeness to start off with, followed mostly by soft, fuzzy positiveness about the cuddly cute trams. Also, a self-deluding reference to the cost of the project being "£545m".

Rumour has it that the completion will be delayed by nine months. As anyone who has been involved in a major capital project know, delay equals extra cost. If the delay is the fault of the "customer" ie TIE, then the extra costs will be severe. My guess, £5m per month, minimum.
32

connaughtboy,

stonehaven 22/06/2009 15:58:52
#7 SS

Not if they are not to blame for the delay.
33

Thomas the Tank,

Edinburgh 22/06/2009 16:38:14
#2, Nope, as far as my mole is aware, there are still some serious engineering and design issues to be resolved. In order to get safe clearance for two of their massive, articulated trams passing at that point, they will have to pass so close to the National Portrait Gallery that any pedestrians are likely to get creamed. Also, providing the necessary superelevation on the corner will create a massive 'humph' for traffic east or west in Queen Street.
34

Caora Dubh,

22/06/2009 21:03:59
Taxpayers are forking out £545 million for a tramline that is just 12 miles long and took years to construct. The tramline is a luxury, not a necessity. The NHS could have done with that money, as could have council housing, and school repairs. I have used buses to and from Turnhouse - express & slow. In my view the decision to construct the tramline was criminal when weighted against other needs.
35

El Franko,

29/06/2009 16:57:35
Not a cost-effective use of £545m. The economics will look even worse as the real budget grows.
36

Jimmy Jester,

Dundee 16/07/2009 15:52:55
You can't make omelettes without breaking eggs -- but that's easy for me to say as I don't live here. Roll on the trams, although there will be an awfy lot of passengers having to stand. Aye, Welcome to Edinburgh.

Following my own visit yesterday, I agree with Charles Linskaill (June 22) regarding the Scottish Grot Shop. "It's Princes Street, Jim... but not as we know it!" Why on earth does the council's environmental health department allow this aggressive assault on our ears? Can I claim against them for personal injury, perchance? I hurried past as quickly as I could, but with all the pavement congestion...!! According to their posters, the shop is closing down. I don’t believe it, but if they are, serves them right; their demise will be Edinburgh’s gain. Praise Be!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.