Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


OAPs paid £1500 to move out of homes

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 23 February 2009
PENSIONERS who have lived in an Edinburgh sheltered housing complex for decades are being told to move out – and offered £1500 compensation.
Housing association Castle Rock Edinvar wants to clear its St Stephen's Court facility in Sighthill, because it believes it is not up to modern standards.

But residents are angry that they are being forced to move from a facility some have stayed
in for decades.

The housing association will have to pay each tenant the set fee of £1500 for forcing them to move to alternative housing. And it will also provide removal costs for each flat, which is expected to cost up to £600 each.

Tenants, who are mostly aged 60 or over, will have to either move to other Castle Rock Edinvar accommodation or join the EdIndex social housing list, where they will be given "silver" or "gold" priority status, meaning that they have the same priority for accommodation as someone who is classified as homeless.

But there is already a shortage of social housing, and the EdIndex system is receiving an average of 413 "bids" for each social house that becomes available.

Resident Yvonne Louden, 59, added: "I'm one of the younger ones in the block and I'm afraid that I won't get another sheltered housing space, and that they'll just dump me in social housing."

Neighbour Gladys Smith, 63, said: "I only moved in here 10 months ago, and I can't face moving again."

Sandy Welsh, head of housing services at Castle Rock Edinvar, insisted the facility would not be closed until all residents have found alternative accommodation. He said: "We have been looking for some time at what their long-term future is.

"We think it is better to phase the closure, and relocate tenants to our other housing developments or work with other parties to house them in other sheltered housing or council accommodation.

"We have found that, when vacancies arise on EdIndex, there are no bids, or few bids, for them. They are not an area or style of property that is still popular with people."

The future of the flats after they close is not yet decided. It is likely that the housing association will either demolish them and rebuild a new facility or sell to another company for development.

It is also thought that they could provide council homeless accommodation – although the council currently has no such plans.

A spokeswoman for the city council said: "Castle Rock Edinvar has a responsibility to co-ordinate alternative and suitable accommodation for the current tenants. A range of housing options will be made available to them, one of which is to use the council-managed EdIndex housing allocation system.

"We are approached regularly to consider using empty properties for housing purposes. Once this accommodation is vacated completely, we would consider fully any proposals put to us by Castle Rock Edinvar."

'The strain of it is making us ill'
ST Stephen's Court's oldest resident, Phyllis Denyer, has lived in her sheltered housing property for 13 years and now considers it her home.

The 93-year-old walks with a frame and is partially deaf. She fears for the future when the facility eventually closes by March next year.

Her daughter Coral Adsett, 71, also lives in St Stephen's Court and helps care for her, but now the pair fear they may be separated by plans to close the facility.

Coral said: "Castle Rock has promised to try to keep us together, but it has not said where we're going to go, so we don't know how true that is. The strain of it is making us both ill."

Castle Rock recently put up the rent on the single-person bed-sits to £330, which residents thought was excessive at the time, but many would now pay even more to stay put.

Phyllis said: "I don't want to go. I've always been happy here, and I don't know if I'll be as happy in another place.

"There's no point worrying about the inevitable, but it's keeping me awake. As long as I get to keep my daughter with me, I hope I'll be OK."





Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 February 2009 10:28 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Care for the Elderly
 
1

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 23/02/2009 12:23:55
No doubt it is a bit of an upset for these people but,if it is not up to standard it has to be done,and they are lucky to get the money offered.
2

Tartan Viking,

23/02/2009 12:51:35
Where in Sighthill is St Stephen's Court about ?
3

bluehead,

edinburgh 23/02/2009 12:54:47
what else can you expect in Edinburgh these days?
the place gets worse by the minute,is it perhaps to sell the space?,after all who really cares about older people?the whole of Edinburgh is deteriating at an alarming speed,and this is just another example,of the mess it is in
nobody cares anymore!!!!!!!
4

elayne,

23/02/2009 13:03:03

Tenants, who are mostly aged 60 or over, will have to either move to other Castle Rock Edinvar accommodation or join the EdIndex social housing list, where they will be given "silver" or "gold" priority status, meaning that they have the same priority for accommodation as someone who is classified as homeless.

shocking!if these old folk are being moved they should be given new homes,no silly "priority" rubbish,,,no bidding, it is enough upheavel for them,and any bets they will be waiting for ages because some chav or junkie will be deemed "more in need!"its all wrong!
5

The real dracula,

23/02/2009 15:01:48
This unfair to the residents. The building is already there housing is in short supply so surely it would make more sense to bring them up to scratch. The residents dont seem to be complaining so it cant be that bad surely.
£360 is a lot to pay for a bedsit.
6

SHUK,

UK National 23/02/2009 22:45:42
May I most cordially comment that if the same happens in Scotland as the rest of the UK they will tell you that they are going to build affordable housing on the site. However, what they do not tell you is that the knock flat value of the land is probably in the order of , say £2m, and the sell it with planning permission to build affordable homes on the site. Housing association gets £2m, somebody else pays to build affordable homes. Profit £2m. Loss account vulnerable and elderly who are
ejected from their homes. Assuming that the 'Decent
Homes Standards' are the same in Scotland as they are in
England then what constitutes a Decent Home is a pretty low standard and you have to fail three from a list of six to be declared substandard.

At least 10 Sheltered schemes are taking their landlords to court in England on the basis that they have had 'Legitimate Expectations' unilaterally withdrawn and another possible action under 'An irrational decision' to move elderly in this manner .

Incidentally the usual price they pay to move people here is £4000, plus disturbance allowance . So you might want to query the paltry £1500 offered ?

chairman
The Sheltered Housing UK Association
www.shelteredhousinguk.com
7

keit011,

23/02/2009 23:03:22
this sounds like the castle rock usual standard of renting out houses that need renovated or totally gutted iam in one and have spent a few grand trying to get it looking ok but still a long way to go the Scottish government should do something about the standard of houses that are for let this one we have was like a flood damaged house you would see on the news
8

alfonsa pedrosa,

embra 24/02/2009 11:28:54
#2
It must be on the Broomhouse side,which is not Sighthill where i was born.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.