Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Bullies drove me to attempt suicide

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
05 March 2007
THE razor blade cut into Paula Thorburn's arm, scoring open the flesh and releasing a steady stream of warm, sticky blood.
It didn't hurt much - not compared to the pain she had felt day in and day out, tormented and teased by teenage bullies who had left her fearing high school and wishing she was dead.

She nearly achieved that too, she nods, recalling how she lifted a bottle of painkillers prescribed to help her cope with the thumping migraine headaches that plagued her... and methodically swallowed more than a dozen pills before lying down to die.

That she didn't end it there and then was luck - a few more of the paracetamol and codeine-based tablets and Paula, now a softly spoken college student with hopes of one day becoming a writer, might well be dead.

"I don't really know what was going through my head," she admits, now 17 and remembering the cloudy haze that fogged her thoughts as the drugs took hold and an overwhelming desire to sleep enveloped her body.

"I suppose I thought if I did it, killed myself, then I wouldn't be in this pain any more - no-one would be able to hurt me again."

Today her teenage anguish, the self-harming and several frightening attempts to kill herself have all been replaced with a burning anger. Furious over the way her education was shattered by vicious tormentors, she has embarked on a bold attempt to sue Edinburgh City Council for failing to protect her.

Her legal action - she is now waiting for legal aid chiefs to consider her application for funding - would be her second journey to the Scottish courts. When she was still just 14 years old she became only the second person in Scottish legal history to be issued with an interdict to protect her from another 14-year-old girl at her school, Tynecastle High. Today Paula reflects with sadness on a miserable time spent dodging the bullies who teased her for her red hair, and, cruelly, for her disability. At just six years old she underwent surgery to remove cataracts from her eyes, leaving her partially blind and wearing thick glasses.

"I was having such a bad time, I was in my room and I had these tablets, Migraleve, to take for the cluster headaches that I got," she says. "I took probably 15 of them and started to feel dizzy and sick.

"I didn't think about how what I was doing would upset my mum, I just wanted it all to end. I got so sleepy I lay on my bed and didn't think about waking up."

Luckily she did, but would repeat the episode twice more.

"I was so self-conscious," she recalls. "I had this carrot-coloured, gingery hair, glasses, and people started to pick on me. I was about 12 years old.

"Until then I liked school, then after it started, I didn't want to go back. The worst bit was when someone shoved me in the back when I was walking downstairs. I fell down 20 steps." She claims she landed in front of a teacher who just looked at her and told her to get up and go to her class.

There were many other incidents - both at Tynecastle and later at Currie High, where Paula went to escape her tormentors, only to be bullied there too.

On one occasion, desperate to get away from her antagonists, she fled out of the school building and into the path of an oncoming bus, narrowly escaping being knocked down.

While Paula has now left the bullies behind and is working to catch up on her education at college, shocking figures just released from the ChildLine charity have revealed there are hundreds of girls in the same state today that Paula was.

They are so despairing of their lives that they are seriously considering killing themselves. According to the counselling service, four out of every five calls UK-wide involved discussions with girls about their suicidal feelings, with around 1100 Scots children calling to discuss mental health issues such as depression.

ChildLine counsellors have now called on Government ministers to tackle the shortages of specialist therapists to help troubled children through bullying, mental issues, family troubles, exam stress and eating disorders.

"When young people talk about suicide they are obviously in deep despair," says assistant director of ChildLine Joelle Leader. "They are at crisis point with no one else to turn to, which is why they call us.

"The number of children who rang to talk about mental health issues last year in the UK could have filled 250 classrooms, so it's a big problem."

"We are able to give immediate advice to these young people, who are going through a terrifying experience, but it is clear that those who call us with serious problems may need more intensive therapeutic support over a sustained period.

"At the moment, there are simply not enough therapeutic services for children with these problems, and we are urging the Government to give this issue urgent attention."

News that there are still major flaws in the way troubled children are offered support deeply concerns Paula, of Baird Drive, Saughtonhall. "I wouldn't want anyone to go through that," she says. "I tried to tell my headteacher at Tynecastle, but I was told to go to a guidance teacher who, as far as I could see, didn't do anything to stop it.

"My advice to anyone going through this today is to stand up to the bullies and don't let them win - but that's not easy."

For Jacqueline Wallace, 40, Paula's mum, watching her younger daughter crumble at the hands of bullies was a nightmare - and it has fired her determination to hold the city council to account. "If we get legal aid we will go to court - as long as Paula feels she can cope with it," she says.

"The bottom line is that they should not get away with having let things get as far as they did with Paula, no-one should. We firmly believe they were in the wrong, that they didn't help her when she wanted help. We went through a lot of channels, there were lots of chances for them to do the right thing. Instead, they spent more time putting pressure on me for keeping her at home from school - I once had a social worker at the house telling me it was all my fault and that I didn't care enough about Paula's future.

"I said 'get the hell out of my house' but they kept threatening me and said they'd take Paula away from me - things which were said in front of Paula. My daughter ended up seeing a psychiatrist - and I blame the council for that."

She removed Paula from high school for almost 18 months, determined not to send her back into an environment in which she could be bullied again. Eventually education officials agreed to fund a place at an independent school - Dunedin School in Gilmerton Road - where Paula completed her secondary education.

The interdict in 2004, explains Jacqueline, was the only route she could think to take to try to stop the Tynecastle High bullying, even though it wasn't totally effective.

"We heard about a girl up north who had become the first in Scotland to do this because she was being bullied," Jacqueline explains. "It was a big step, but what else could we do? We felt that no-one was listening to us and that Paula needed protection because we were really scared for what might happen next.

"The bullying wasn't just in school and it wasn't just one person. There were about 20 kids in all, boys and girls. They'd watch me leaving the house, knock on the door and try to get Paula to come out so there'd be a fight.

"The worst thing is that as a parent, you are an adult and you know you're dealing with kids, but it was more than just one - there was a group of them."

For Paula, the nightmare of her schooldays is in the past. She sometimes sees some of her tormentors, now either pregnant, single mums or on drugs, she says. "I was scared of them for a long time," she adds, remembering what should have been the best days of her life but were actually the worst. "Now, I'm just angry."

For the council, Andrew Burns, executive member for children and families, says: "It is not appropriate to comment on individual cases. However, we take all incidents of bullying extremely seriously in all of our establishments. The Children and Families Department has recently issued revised guidelines - Positively Challenging Bullying Racism and Discrimination, which we hope will promote a culture where raising concerns is encouraged, and in which everyone accepts their responsibility to positively challenge bullying and other forms of discrimination and harassment.

"We have a wide range of initiatives in place to prevent bullying, including buddying systems, peer mentoring, playground supervision and befriending schemes.

"Proactive and preventative work also includes curricular activities such as circle time and personal and social development in primary, secondary and special schools.

"During 2006, the Children and Families Department also participated in two parent information night events, where our anti-bullying initiatives were showcased."

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 05 March 2007 2:31 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Bullying at school
 
1

Harry Haggis,

05/03/2007 13:07:42

Does anyone else notice how inappropriate the advert links at the bottom of this article are? Come on Scotsman get a grip.

2

port seton boy,

at work 05/03/2007 13:11:50

Most schools turn a blind etye and deny they have a bullying problem. Headmasters/mistresses echo not in my school never. Schools get a grip!

3

sergiesmax,

05/03/2007 13:41:12

i feel for you it happend to me also at school so i just never went but things turn out good sometimes good luck with getting legal aid its about time someone took responsibility for this problem.

4

5-A-Day Phil,

05/03/2007 14:00:59

Not only are the adverts inappropriate (to say the least!) but the article also contravenes good practice guidelines by, in particular, giving the drug and dosage used in a suicide attempt.

It is also lamentable that although ChildLine was noted as a potential source of support no contact detils were given for this or any of the other agencies that may be of help.

Childline's telephone number is 0800 1111

Samaritans' telephone number is 0845 909090
or E-mail jo@samaritans.org

5

alex paterson,

embra 05/03/2007 14:07:56

#1Yes,#2 very true,Punch them back,Itll soom stop.

6

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 05/03/2007 14:19:59

Adverts for razor blades on a page about an un fortunate soul who cut herself with a razor.
Apalling and tasteless..

7

Brianwci,

www.edinburghtechniques.co.uk 05/03/2007 15:17:16

I long ceased to be fan of the Unionist Scotsman but in fairness to them these adverts apear automatically on all webpages where a keyword appears, in this case razor.

No one has chosen these adverts to appear. The Scotsman editorial may have gone Unionist but it hasn't gone senile.

8

Blondie,

05/03/2007 16:00:45

Maybe one idea would be for schools to teach children to have more self-esteem and self-belief as well as how to stand up for themselves, right from the beginning of their education. The "anti-bullying policies" they have in place at the moment certainly don't seem to be doing much good.

9

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 05/03/2007 16:26:11

#7
That might explain it but it doesn't make it right.

10

elayne,

fife 05/03/2007 16:34:09

bullying is rife,i feel so sad this girl has had to suffer at the hands of bullys,it happens too much,but one thing has always rung true"get a bully on his/her own,then they are not so tough"if you get my meaning!.schools are not tough enough on bullying,because the pc brigade have taken away any decent forms of disipline,suspensions and exclusions,well kids just laugh at things like that.bullys are seldom tough when alone,its the pack mentality,plus bullys are usually inadequate in some way,dumb,stupid,illiterate etc so they target someone who is perhaps quiet and studious but it is THEM who are the stupid ones,and should be dealt with for the social inadequates that they are,and should be named and shamed

11

Bonny Lady,

Edinburgh 05/03/2007 16:34:29

Agree - these adverts are appalling!

Complained once before about their adverts and they said there was nothing they could do.

Feel free to report my message as unsuitable and maybe they'll actually look at what's on their website.

12

TheRedHead,

Edinburgh 05/03/2007 17:11:07

Nothing like a big fat sum of money to make all your bad memories disappear eh? Along with a fantastically written 2 page spread in the newspaper, which some of the language could be straight out of an international best-seller, describing you at your lowest moments.

She must feel tonnes better…

In my own opinion this is a complete joke. Almost everyone gets bullied sometime at school. You have to adapt. It won’t be changing for a long time, so stop being utterly shallow by suing people right, left and centre and shouting from the rooftops that you were bullied.

And to use the “hair colour” as torment…well speaking as a redhead, yes it happens & isn’t pleasant. The cure is to hit back at them, giving them abuse for their weight and other forms of appearance. Yet we all know this works, just choose not to use it.

Who was it that once said we will all have 15 seconds of fame? This girl has certainly got hers.

13

Agent 99,

05/03/2007 17:30:35

[7] is right. [9] is simply misguided.

The paper sells advertising space. The web ads are inserted based on a scan of the article, looking for kewords. Surely you don't expect program logic to be blessed with good taste?

There might be a case for classifying certain articles such that no advertising space is reserved on their pages. But you can't expect the cash-hungry Hootsmon group and its reporters to be that sensitive; can you?

[12] RedHead: Dead right, spot on. This article should be in a more appropriate publication, but I'll leave the choice of which one to others here.

14

Mr C,

Edinburgh 05/03/2007 17:46:10

School must be a terrifying place for some youngsters but also for teachers who have their hands completely tied they are supposed to teach in a climate of fear - they have little power but all the responsibility.

My thoughts are that there needs to be far more supervision going on and cut down on the break times where this bullying usually happens - countries like Sweden and Germany only have half days at school and the kids do more studying at home and have more control over their day. I remember my days at school were more of a sensory deprivation centre/glorified babysitters club. I think Paula is doing a very positive thing, not just for herself but this could change the lives of many other people in her situation who feel helpless - Good luck!

15

Repton,

edinburgh 05/03/2007 17:59:53

Again it`s the empty vessels that are to blame.These people who bully are inadequetes who see fit to bully because it makes them seem big.The schools should clamp down on it but as they took the tause away I can`t see the problem going away.Schools seem to pussyfoot around the problem instead of confronting it head on.These bullies need sorted .

16

Open Minded,

Not Edinburgh 05/03/2007 18:16:05

#12 The Redhead

Thank goodness my visits to Edinburgh are rare.

I wouldn't want to cross you up a dark alley, That's for sure. A wimp, you are not. Hate to be around you on a bad day / month.

17

Mario Antoinette aka lots of things,

Nederlands 05/03/2007 18:38:53

Things will only get worse, look at the mother.

What ? Im being realistic, its a jungle out there.

18

A Scot in exile,

Canada 05/03/2007 18:57:12

Well said 10, 14, 15. My daughter became suicidal after 9 months of constant bullying and threats by a group of 8 kids and the school said, "Nothing we can do, unless we see it happening". Of course, the bullies were so cowardly they only attacked in hallways/stairwells etc. Several parents and a school crossing guard saw her being swarmed outside the school and complained to the principal, but still nothing was done. After my daughter came home with bruises from an attack ON THE PLAYGROUND, I called the police and had one girl cautioned (the police advised against a charge because the girl would have only received a slap on the wrist). The school gave her a one day, in-school suspension which she chose to do at home - in effect, she was rewarded with a holiday! Personally, I think the principal is afraid to stand up to these kids' parents. As for fighting back, standing up to one bully is fine, but bullies rarely operate alone. Thank goodness it seems to have stopped now, but my daughter will never be the same happy, carefree girl she once was.

19

Robbie,

NZ 05/03/2007 19:07:10

Interesting - those advertisements do not appear on my page. International addition must be different.

20

Pilrig,

Livingston 05/03/2007 19:39:42

12 you were the school bully ? cynical barsteward.
If the teachers, educationists were doing their jobs more effectively bullying would largely cease.

21

,

05/03/2007 19:40:18
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 420089, Article id was mapped to record!
22

simply the best....,

edinburgh 05/03/2007 19:41:28

@12 your hartless aren't you.

23

Conan,

Here 05/03/2007 21:09:56

'Victim' - initiate a civil suit against your tormentors and any/all who make it possible for them to get away with it. Hammer them in their pockets - they'll change their ways, even if reluctantly. All of you being similarly tormented - use the common tort law to level the playing field and get some justice. Fight back - and maybe win.

24

TheRedHead,

Edinburgh 05/03/2007 21:17:07

20 - Is that a question? No I wasn't (to the best of my knowledge).

What this is just another cry for attention. I know a couple of people in my years at school who done the whole "committing suicide" thing & it isn't clever, but it gets the job of getting you noticed(could you see this article making the paper if she DIDNT?)

22 - Heartless isn't the word. I would say realistic. I know enough not to jump straight onto the soppy storyline and start giving the "That is terrible" proclaims.

We know bullying is wrong, and it is part of life. I don't see why it justifies writing into the papers...

25

,

05/03/2007 21:30:56
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
26

Liz Carnell / Bullying Online,

Harrogate 05/03/2007 21:34:31

It really is terrible to have an advert for razor blades on a story where a suicidal girl has tried to cut her wrists.

Schools need to be tougher on bullies, far too many of them are using low key methods of dealing with incidents, including assaults, when they should be calling in the police.

The charity Bullying Online website has lots of practical advice and information for parents looking for help on sorting a problem out and for young people who have perhaps had their friends taken away or are suffering cyber bullying. People can also email us through the contact button on the website.

I won't post the url of the site in case that isn't allowed, but you can find it by simply typing the word bullying into Google.
Liz Carnell
Bullying Online

27

Julian,

06/03/2007 00:29:39

Redhead # 24, what about the 600 people last year who did the "commiting suicide thing" and actually died?
You presume a lot to say that it was just a cry for help. Are you some sort of expert?

28

Angus Lindsay,

Shenzhen, China 06/03/2007 03:42:39

#12 Redhead

#16, 20, 22 have you on the spot.

Your post is a heap of cynicism. A justification of a foul practice. I may not personally agree with the "sue them at all cost" lobby, but can understand the reasoning. I was bullied during my otherwise happy primary school years by a cowardly scumbag. Occasionally a bigger lad came to my rescue and to him I owe many thanks. The bully, however, would continue in psychological mode, threatening this and that after school. He maintained me in a state of fear.

Bullies invariably seek a punchbag for their own inadequacies and my experience of this no different from others. In my far-off schooldays there were no helplines or other agencies to complain to. Parents took little or no notice either. I learned to tough it out, and on approaching secondary school age also began to fill out physically. How interesting that the bullying ceased ... As a young adult I came across my former tormentor at a Friday night dance. He was then married with four children, out on the lash. Still the same boastful piece of scum. Some things never change.

#12 says "Almost everyone gets bullied sometime at school. You have to adapt."

That's a neat statistic and the "advice" to adapt and "hit back at them" is meaningless to someone who is (usually) physically inferior. Torment takes many forms, whether hair colour, as you #12 mention, or clothing, or having intelligence, or parents' social standing. The broad brush approach of "we all know this works" is fantasy.

I think #20 hit a raw nerve. You talk like a bully, Mr #12.

29

Pilrig,

Livingston 06/03/2007 06:02:38

24 - it was a question.

You prefer the problem was swept under the carpet.
Hmm.... the attitude of the staff at Tynie High and the City Chambers.

30

Yane,

woop woop 06/03/2007 06:53:37

#12 It was Andy Warhol & it was "in the future everyone will have 15 minutes of fame".
I think she's a lovely looking girl & should be proud of her red hair -- over here it's quite unusual.
Shows quite lot of bravery to come forward I think.
I don't think everyone does get bullied at school TheRedHead.

31

TheRedHead,

Edinburgh 06/03/2007 16:50:21

Julian #27 – 600 out of how many attempted? Furthermore, how many committed suicide directly related to school bullying? Elaborate please….
I may be presuming a lot, and it can be directly out of my experiences, which in itself is not objective. People who have children of their own, or work with children will realise that certain issues the kids have ca get blown out of proportion. In this instance it is my belief that this is exactly what has happened.

Angus Lindsay #28 – You have been misguided while reading my posts its seems. I am amazed you can claim I am trying to justify bullying. At no point (in my own understanding of what I have written) am I supporting, or justifying a bully’s actions. My issue is while the public display that one person gets when this is a global problem.
Your own story of how you were bullied does not make pleasant reading, it is sad that it happens. It is a very widespread problem and I do not understand why the girl in this article is suing for herself and her own damages when clearly a large number of kids (and adults) get bullied. A rather selfish action considering. (Not as selfish as the bullies obviously)
#28 states: “The broad brush approach of "we all know this works" is fantasy.”
I aimed to stick on topic as the rules of this posting state and in this girl’s case, hitting back seems a viable option. You know as well as I do that it doesn’t apply in every situation so avoid stating the obvious.
And as for talking like a bully, we have already seem how the complex nature of how are brain interprets language can cause confusion and conflict. In your mind you see my writing as bullying. The article itself communicates different things for different people, so the posts below are sure to do the same.

Pilrig #29 – Pilrig Lets get things into perspective. I have stated bullying is a global problem. Hardly sweeping it under the carpet?
In my opi

32

,

06/03/2007 23:57:05
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.