Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Ming the bashful shrugs off his knighthood for common touch

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 22 November 2006
WHILE Tony Blair waves a tea mug in Downing Street and David Cameron pedals on a bike to work, Sir Menzies Campbell has found a new way to demonstrate his street cred - by downplaying his knighthood.
It emerged yesterday that the 65-year-old Liberal Democrat leader has been dropping his "sir" on documents such as the party's press releases.

The official biography section of his website - www.mingcampbell.com
- also features no mention of his knighthood and refers to him throughout as "Ming" and not "Menzies".

Political opponents last night accused Sir Menzies of trying to cultivate a "man of the people" image.

The move also drew parallels with the former Labour MP Tony Benn, who renounced his title as Second Viscount Stansgate Anthony Wedgwood-Benn for its more prosaic alternative.

Some fellow MPs last night claimed the move was a clear attempt to make the QC and Glasgow University graduate appear more earthy.

Steve Pound, the Labour MP, said: "It's a bit late in the day for him to be discovering the common touch. At this rate they will soon be calling him 'your mate, Ming'. But at his age, I'm afraid it's doomed to fail."

Sir Menzies, the MP for North East Fife and a former Olympic sprinter, was conferred his title in 2004.

A Lib Dem party spokesman last night insisted the move, introduced a fortnight ago, was "not a big issue", adding: "We just decided to do it. It is only on his press releases; he is still Sir Menzies in correspondence."

'TREMENDOUS HONOUR'


SIR Arnold Clark, the head of the 7,000-employee car company, received his knighthood in 2004 - 50 years after starting the business that carries his name. He said: "It is a tremendous honour to be recognised for my services to the motor industry and to the Scottish community."

The businessman added: " I am happy to be referred to as either 'Sir Arnold' or 'Mr Clark' by staff, colleagues or friends. I would prefer those introductions than 'the old guy'."

Sir Arnold, 78, the chairman and chief executive of the company, revealed he had gone straight back to work after the investiture at the Palace of Holyroodhouse.

Sir Arnold also said that he had shared a joke with the Queen as she bestowed the honour. The Queen, told of his half-century in cars, told him: "Well, it certainly doesn't look as though you've been 50 years in the motor trade."

He later said: "It's never been an arduous task going to my business in the morning, so doing something you love doing and getting an award is a bonus."

FEELGOOD TITLE


SIR Tom Farmer, the founder of the Kwik-Fit chain, received his knighthood in 1997.

"On occasions when someone introduces me as 'Sir Tom Farmer' when I'm going to speak, I feel very good and wish my old teachers and mum and dad could hear it.

"What I don't want is it to be used all the time. If I'm in company, I do find myself saying to people: 'Listen, my name is Tom, that's exactly what my mum called me, and I'd like everyone else to call me the same'.

"There are occasions when it's used and I think: I like hearing that."

Asked if there were any down sides to being a Sir, he replied: "I haven't come across any."

The businessman, who also has a CBE, recalled that soon after receiving his knighthood, he had heard his new title announced in public by the master of ceremonies before a speech.

Sir Tom asked his audience: "Ladies and gentlemen, I wonder if I could do something very personal.

"I have never heard that said before. Would you mind if I asked the master of ceremonies to do it again?"

PLAIN OLD RICHARD


FAMED for his casual and occasionally intrepid style, Richard Branson was probably an unlikely candidate to parade the knighthood he received in the millennium honours. Will Whitehorn, the entrepreneur's press spokesman, said: "He is always Richard. We will often put 'Sir Richard Branson said' in press releases because that's his title. If he meets somebody, the last thing he would expect to be called is Sir Richard. He doesn't put it in his own correspondence when he writes to people.

"When it is an official document to a government body then we would sign it Sir Richard Branson."

The Virgin head was an early pioneer of the tieless look in business. His dislike of suited formality even led him to try and remove the tie of Jack McConnell, the First Minister, when the pair sat together for a press call at Edinburgh Airport on the eve of the G8 summit at Gleneagles.

A light-hearted Branson tried to take off the First Minister's tie for the cameras, joking: "He's even younger than I am."

INFORMALITY FIRST


LORD Tim Garden knows more than most about honours, having been knighted before becoming a Liberal Democrat peer in the House of Lords. The former assistant chief of the defence staff and RAF air marshal said: "Before people called me Sir Timothy, then when you get a peerage you're not allowed to use your first name.

"As far as I'm concerned, when anybody knows me, I'm Tim Garden, when I go up to somebody and introduce myself, I always say 'Hi, I'm Tim Garden'. There are occasions when you are giving prizes at a school, or you are drawing the raffle at some great event, where it's a bit like being the mayor of somewhere - the organisation likes to feel they're grander because they've got somebody with a title."

The peer said he was struck by how formal the House of Lords was. "It was a bit like going back to my school days; people don't like the use of first names," he said. Receiving his knighthood in 1994 was "fantastic". He added: "Although people talk about them coming with the rations, they are few and far between in the military and civil service."



Page 1 of 1

 
1

Keren,

22/11/2006 02:37:02

'Sir' Ming is a total prat and no fancy title will ever change that.

Tell us about the Arctic Monkeys selling more CD's than The Beatles again your 'sir' ship!!!"!

2

Royster,

22/11/2006 06:21:19

Intelligent, well-meaning and totally useless on the floor of Westminster. Bring back Kennedy, a drop of whisky never did Churchill any harm.

3

Tam O' Shanter,

Ayr 22/11/2006 08:00:54

Reminds me of David Steel at the dawn of the Scottish parliament.
"I know I am Lord Steel but you can call me Sir David".

4

Rubbersnap,

Magdalene 22/11/2006 09:06:56

I am reminded of Sir Ian McKellen, who famously said ... "Hello, I am Sir Ian McKellen ... but you can call me Serena!"

:)

PS ... (Sir) Elton John started that!

And anyway, the ONLY man who I ever agreed to call "sir", was my late grandad.

I dislike titles immensely! The late great Lord Provost, Jack Kane eschewed the title when it was offered. A true 'man of the peple' ... he had no use for such things either.

5

AJ,

Fife 22/11/2006 10:23:10

He is a champion freeloader and deserves his title. Anybody who sponges aff the State as much as he does, shows dedication beyond the call of duty.

Coupled with the fact he leads a Party, that as no influence whatsoever, and yet, he is still held in such high regard by his Peers. This underlines skillful use of the "old school tie network" and is a tribute to his masterful use of "sooking in".

Also, he is the Pan Loafiest of any current Scottish politician!

Well done Ming.

6

Jeeemy,

Fife 22/11/2006 10:55:06

Reading all of the above, makes me laugh and at the same time makes me sick.
if the above are a sample of the "chattering" classes in Scotland then I feel it is time to leave.
It is glaringly obvious to me that This paper it's editor and it's reporters have been given a task from someone on high to do a sniping job on Ming.
have anyone of you met the man. from the above writings no.
I am not a party card carrier, but I have met the man and I do feel that he is the most genuine Politician in Westminster.

7

Neil,

0% Growth party 22/11/2006 12:01:43

"Environment environment environment" Campbell told the world that we should stop global warming by putting in low power light bulbs & when asked how many of the light bulbs in his house were low power said "Well none". The guy hasn't got a clue what he stands for but has been told Liberalism is all about the environment & is trying it.

8

James England,

22/11/2006 12:06:18

Did he buy his Knighthood for supporting Blair on many major issues?

9

Jockyw,

22/11/2006 12:11:49

He would have better 'street cred' to have turned down the offer of a knighthood rather that not use it on his stationary.
The fact is he's still a 'Sir'.

10

Royster,

22/11/2006 12:15:10

#7. Trouble with being genuine is that you are either a) a fanatic (I'm sure Hitler and Stalin were genuine in their own evil ways) or b) useless. Politics is a game and if you don't play like everyone else you lose which means that genuine people make many voters nervous. That's why Clinton was such a bit hit.

11

Arthur,

22/11/2006 12:20:47

Yeh, I've met this former athlete socially a couple of times, and he comes across as quite genuine, and not at all pan loafy. He has the same ability as my goodself
in adjusting his manner of communication to make the recipient of said communication feel comfortable.
He has also suffered the great sadness of placing his beloved XJS in Myreton motor museum as it wasn't environmentally friendly. I woudn't take issue with his advanced years, many an old horse has made a valuable contribution to the political life of this country.
Just recall Winnie, and Mannie and Ming the Merciful is still fit of Physique and Mind. Don't knock it till you've tried it.
Article itself does suggest a slow news day though.

12

Tony B,

22/11/2006 12:33:34

Can anyone enlighten me as to what Ming has actually achieved in order to be given a knighthood?

13

Nigel,

Dunfermline 22/11/2006 12:37:18

I see Sir Mingers staff have been busy on this thread...yeah, he's just one of us, aye right !

How many Jags did he give up for "the environment" and how many does he still have ?

Lies, damned lies and Liberal Democrats.

14

KeithL,

Fife 22/11/2006 12:46:37

Nigel #15 -

One and none.

There. Happy now?

15

KeithL,

Fife 22/11/2006 12:47:20

Actually, looking at where you come from, still feeling a bit bitter?

16

sheena,

Non PC World 22/11/2006 12:48:31

He'll always be 'Ming the Merciless' to me after what he did to Charlie Kennedy.
Saw him years ago at a televised panel discussion. He alone of the panellists was wearing make up!

17

Arthur,

22/11/2006 12:58:26

Imagination, Ignorance, and Nigel from Dunfermline

18

AJ,

Fife 22/11/2006 13:02:27

Tony#14

see earlier comment #6

19

Arthur,

22/11/2006 13:04:25

Sheena, all Ming Did to Charlie was succeed him, It was the party, we are told wanted rid of Charlie.
I dunno what your point is about the make up,dou you? He would not have been the only one, It's needed under studio lights, else your facial features are washed out

20

Nigel,

Dunfermline 22/11/2006 13:47:43

# 16 KeithL

So you didn't like the lies, damned lies and Liberal Democrats bit then !

21

The west awake,

Argyll 22/11/2006 13:55:55

Are we meant to be grateful that he doesn't insist we call him Sir? I'm touched.
I'm glad they elected Ming - more votes for the SNP.

22

sheena,

Non PC World 22/11/2006 14:01:32

Arthur 21: Programme was not in a studio but at Council Headquarters Viewforth, Stirling. Ming ARRIVED wearing thick make up. TV Crew did not have any make up people with them and none of the other panellists nor the audience (excepting those women who usually wear make up) were similarly 'enhanced'. Point is he looked like a prat and one wondered what he was trying to conceal - his age perhaps? BTW I did some canvassing during Dunfermline Bye Election - heard lots of sympathy for CK and nothing favourable about Ming at all.

23

horn,

coming up behind u 22/11/2006 14:35:43

#10, good one, not many folks turn them down!

they mean nothing cos off all the
%ankers who got them from business and politics

the decent people have been undermined

24

Steve,

West Lothian 22/11/2006 14:38:41

Ming is a decrepit old has-been. Just like his colleagues in the Lib Dumbs. What DO the Liberal Democrats stand for? Anyone???

25

Arthur,

22/11/2006 15:03:48

27 Thankyou for your mature and insightful political critique.
At present we have in No. 10 an Fettes FP who should still be under training not at a public school but an approved school.
His heir apparent is a chinless wonder, still struggling with a speech impediment, probably brought on by his strict presbyterian upbringing.
Their allegedly cheif opponent is another chinless, tree hugging, hoodie loving, boy wonder, who is still trying to figure out what he stands for, let alone the party he purportedly leads.
Ming, may be of pensionable age, but he is the most politically experienced of the lot of them.
He and his party quite sensibly stand for sustainable
use of renewble energy, European federation, true responsible liberalism, and are against pointless war
and further restrictions on personal freedoms, this coupled with transfer of taxation to pay for pollution
may not be all you agree with but at least they and he are not sitting on fences tring to be all things to all men, in a vain attempt to cling to power.

26

Jockyw,

22/11/2006 15:16:34

#28 - agree, however Ming has nothing to lose being third in line and by some distance at present.
Labour has spun us all to death and god help us if Gordon Brown or as Jade said on her PA programme Gordon Ramsay (Chancellor) gets into power. The Tories at present are al still looking for inspiration with in.

The British public is looking for inspiration in Govt full stop.

27

The west awake,

Argyll 22/11/2006 15:49:18

Arthur 28 - At present we have in Holyrood a shower of incompetent, vision-free muppets kept there through an opportunist deal with the LDs.
Apart from banging on about tution fees, PR and free care for the elderly, which were done ages ago and in the case of the latter is still to be proved, what benefits have the people of Scotland got for the price of the LDs sitting at the big boys table?
Sure Labour could rule alone for now, but without partners it would make life very difficult for them. The LDs bear responsibility for the atrocious standard of governance in this country, true or false?

28

Arthur,

22/11/2006 16:04:00

I wouldn't know sadly I don't live in Scotia anymore
at least elderly care is better than in England as is
the student situation, under labour alone.
The issue, however, is Westminster Govt. which is where Ming sits.

29

W Smith,

Middle East 22/11/2006 16:43:24

#29 Jockyw - agreed!

the term 'Leadership Crisis' comes to mind.

Correct me if I'm wrong but I think I am right in saying Scoland has:

1. the worst performing economy in the EU.
2. more oil and gas reserves than any other country in the EU (remember Norway is not in the EU)

Does Ming look worried/concerned/ determined to put this right?

My concern is that 10 years from now Lord Gordon Brown will be sitting next to Lord Michael Forsyth and Lord Tony Blair in the House of Lords- but Scotland will still be in this underperfoming mess while Ireland's oil reserveless economy powers ahead!

Scotand's in the relegation zone and whose ever heard of a football manager getting a kinghthood for getting his team relegated!

I'm not sure yet about the SNP but if they can send a shock wave through this nation then good luck to them!

30

Neil,

9% Growth party 22/11/2006 16:56:28

Arthur 28
"Ming, may be of pensionable age, but he is the most politically experienced of the lot of them.
He and his party quite sensibly stand for sustainable
use of renewble energy, European federation, true responsible liberalism, and are against pointless war
and further restrictions on personal freedoms, this coupled with transfer of taxation to pay for pollution"

They stand for 100% dependence on windmills & for not even trying to extend the life of Hunterston beyond 2011, without explaining what they can replace it stop blackouts being inevitable. It is true they support "ever closer union" with Brussels. Any party which has no place for those who believe in the free market policies of Adam Smith certainly do not believe in liberalism, "responsible" or otherwise. Their position on crimianl wars is undeniably supportive as proven by their involvement in war to help the Nazi KLA commit genocide. A party committed to political correctness officers thoughout industry to usurpe the jobs of owners & to banning smokers is not committed to freedom. Their pollution taxes, as far as currently disclosed, would be expensive to collect & would merely result in higher taxeation & more bureaucracy to raise the same money.

They are unworthy of the term liberal.

31

Enjoy the football first,

22/11/2006 22:55:50

Ooh, a knighthood. Just like a thousand other party-favours given out for nothing genuinely meaningful.

The real prats are the ones who accept the title in the first place.

Too late for 'Ming' to avoid making that mistake, eh?

32

Steve,

23/11/2006 00:35:23

Someone asked what the Lib Dems stand for....

Lib Dems=slippery political opportunists of the very worst kind. The tail that wagged the dog. Unscrupilous and power obsessed. If there's a by-election, they'll be first on the scene, bussing in canvassers from as far away as Cornwall. Deceiptful campaigns. Say one thing on the doorstep, and another in the voting lobby. Claim credit for the few successes of the Scottish Parliament, but take none of the blame for all the failures.

I'd vote for any of the others before I'd vote for them. Middle class wannabes.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.