Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Cash-for-honours case may be to blame for lack of glitz in Blair's second-last list

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 16 June 2007
CRICKET legend Ian Botham and the novelist Salman Rushdie are knighted today in the Queen's Birthday Honours list.
Honours have also been bestowed on Scots from all walks of life, from senior political leaders to local charity workers.

Sir Ian "Beefy" Botham, who took 383 Test wickets and scored more than 5,000 runs for England, said he was delighted at the a
ward, which was bestowed for his numerous charity walks for leukaemia research, including several between John o' Groats and Land's End.

He is not the only cancer campaigner honoured today. Jane Tomlinson, who has terminal cancer, has raised £1.5 million for charity with a series of gruelling triathlons, marathons and long-distance cycle rides. Her MBE has been upgraded to CBE.

Sir Salman, best known for The Satanic Verses - which drew a fatwa from Iran - said he was "thrilled and humbled and very grateful".

Tony Blair's penultimate honours list - he will propose another as he resigns later this month - is remarkably short of the sort of showbiz glamour that has characterised some of his government's nominations.

That may reflect a reluctance by some public figures to accept awards from a government still subject to a police inquiry into cash-for-honours allegations.

Persistent Whitehall rumours have suggested that the Prime Minister's team struggled to find high-profile names for the list.

The most flamboyant celebrity honoured is surely Barry Humphries. The entertainer is awarded a CBE. "I'm deeply honoured. At last I can address Sir Les Patterson and Dame Edna Everage on an improved footing," he said, referring to his infamous comic alter egos.

Peter Sallis, 86, the Last of the Summer Wine actor who provides the voice of Gromit in the Wallace and Gromit films, is made an OBE.

Nicky Clarke, one of the original celebrity hairdressers, is also awarded an OBE.

One of the more surprising political awards is a CBE for Shami Chakrabarti, the director of civil rights group Liberty and an outspoken critic of the government's anti-terrorism strategy. "I hope it will send a timely signal that democratic dissent is not disloyalty," she said.

In a move that may anger government critics, Martin Howard, a senior Ministry of Defence official, is made a Companion of the Order of the Bath.

Mr Howard, as deputy director of defence intelligence, was centrally involved in the 2002 Downing Street dossier claiming Iraq held weapons of mass destruction, and has been accused of suppressing reports from analysts questioning the dossier's assertions.

Another notable figure from the intelligence world, Oleg Gordievsky, the highest-ranking Soviet spy to defect to the West, is appointed a Companion of the Most Distinguished Order of Saint Michael and Saint George (CMG) - the honour held by James Bond.

The Scot given the greatest honour is Charlie Gray, 78, a councillor for 49 years, who is awarded a knighthood. He once led Strathclyde Regional Council and was education convener at North Lanarkshire Council until he stood down in May.

He described his knighthood as "a very special honour".

The former Scottish Prison Service chief executive, Tony Cameron, is made a Companion of the Order of the Bath, and Barbara Kelly, a former chairman of the Scottish Consumer Council, becomes a dame.

Tayside Chief Constable John Vine, whose force was responsible for policing at the Gleneagles G8 summit two years ago, is awarded a CBE.

Audrey Findlay, a member of Aberdeenshire Council for 19 years and a former leader, becomes a CBE.

The Crimestoppers Scotland chairman, Neil McCulloch, and William McKinlay, the governor-in-charge at Glasgow's Barlinnie prison, receive OBEs.

Eleanor Bowman, the mother of Radio 1 DJ Edith Bowman, becomes an MBE for charitable services.

Tommy Gilmour, 55, becomes an MBE for services to boxing. Seen as Scotland's most successful promoter and manager, he has been involved in promoting 24 world title fights.

Dunfermline Athletic Football Club's Jim Leishman, becomes an MBE. Mr Leishman, 53, signed as a schoolboy for the club in 1968. He was later to return, first as director of football and then as manager towards the end of the 2004-05 season, saving the club from relegation.

He stepped down from that role in October, to become director of football again.

Honours also go to Ryan Giggs of Manchester United and Wales, and Teddy Sheringham, of Tottenham and England.

But despite recent feverish speculation at Westminster, David Beckham, the former England football captain, does not receive a knighthood today.

MBE FOR SHOWBUSINESS VETERAN - IT'S "MR BEATTIE, ENTERTAINER"

VETERAN comedian Johnny Beattie could not resist cracking a joke about being awarded his MBE - quipping that it probably stood for "Mr Beattie, Entertainer".

The 80-year-old performer, actor and singer has been recognised for his services to entertainment and charity.

Since leaving a shipyard job as an electrician, his showbusiness career has spanned more than 55 years and is still going strong - the widowed father-of-four plays pensioner Malcolm Hamilton in BBC soap River City.

Mr Beattie said he would have to try and stop making jokes during his visit to Buckingham Palace.

"It's very nice, and I am very happy about it," he said. "It was a lovely surprise."

As well as performing on stage and television, he has also raised thousands of pounds for charity. One of his current favourite causes is St Margaret's Hospice in Glasgow, which helps terminally ill cancer patients.

JOE COCKER'S OBE SURPRISE

JOE Cocker did not expect an honour as he had lived "too long" in the US.

Once a gas fitter, the gritty-voiced singer rose in the early Sixties touring Sheffield pubs. He had his first UK hit in 1968 with the Beatles song With A Little Help From My Friends.

It was "a genuine surprise", he said, to get an OBE for services to music.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 June 2007 11:32 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Birthday honours
 
1

Boy Wonder,

16/06/2007 03:36:18

Good grief ... does anyone really still value these tarnished things??

Personally, I'm happy to be who I am, with only my well-earned Bsc as the letters after my name, which everyone can aspire to and earn through study. I have no need for "honorary" letters named after a dead Empire!

Yet, they still churn them out. Knighthoods, CBEs, OBEs etc, etc ... Why?? Services to charity?? The real sin is that there is still a NEED for charity at all!

It's past time this medieval practice was ended .... and we got shot of this pestilential and parasitical monarchy too!

Viva la Republica!

2

Expat artist,

home 16/06/2007 04:56:41

My Dad used to say OBE stood for 'other bug*** s efforts'

3

Guga II,

Rockall 16/06/2007 04:59:10

#1 Totally agree.

4

donald,

weegieland 16/06/2007 05:53:40

Labour needs the money

5

Ubi,

Edinburgh 16/06/2007 07:00:37

Other nominations :
Sir Graeme Souness : Services to football transfers
Sir Ronald Biggs : Services to penal policy
Sir Michael Barrymore : Services to men
Sir Mohamed Al-Fayed : Services to taxation
Sir Anthony Blair : Service to self
Sir Ken Bates : Services to probity
Sir Stewart Milne : Services to community
Sir Alex Salmond : Services to devolution
Sir Gordon Brown : Services to spin
Sir Paris Hilton : Services to justice

6

ex councillor,

edinburgh 16/06/2007 07:41:29

wait till you se T. b. leaving list,politicians , they all have personal axes to grind , and all to rarely are they honed for the public good whom shall we the public nominate

7

Masque,

16/06/2007 07:46:19

I'm with #1. BW. My Bsc in Engineering is quite enough for me. But here's a question I have about these "honours".

Why a CBE or MBE and not an OBE? What's the difference? Do you have to do more or less than the other guy to qualify for the C or M rather than the O level? Who decides?? (and who really cares?)

I suppose you have to be very well-known for a Knighthood or Dame. Otherwise why can't the ordinary joe-in-the-street get one? Do they cost more than the M or O BEs?? What's the criteria?

What about these other awards, like business people get. Why do THEY get these things over your average joe? Who profits more?

That's why I despise this system. It's as class conscious as the rest of the rotten British Union!

8

cataibh,

Ach yur seen it 16/06/2007 09:02:16

Oh gosh there are still those who believe there is still a British Empire. Even the old Empire theatre in Inverness went years ago.

9

BK,

Cyberspace 16/06/2007 09:50:32

So how much dosh did Bliar make from this list?
And #7 - it depends on how much you pay for it, as the investigation revealed. A "big P" was stated to cost more than a "K."

10

Chris Price,

Sidcup 16/06/2007 09:59:53

Expat artist (2) - my Mum says EXACTLY the same!!

So how much did this lot pay Blair for THEIR honours?
GOOD GRIEF! You mean, they DIDN'T!! How will the poor boy survive when he leaves New Criminals?...Er.. I mean New Labour....

11

Bystander,

Edinburgh 16/06/2007 11:24:06

As a protest against this corrupt,shabby government I have politely refused the honour offered to me and wish the rest of them had the same principles.

12

Discretionpvs,

Canada 16/06/2007 11:27:09

When I look over the names on the list, I am more than ever glad that Canada abolished this sort of claptrap somewhere around 80 years ago. And don't throw Conrad Black in my face. He gave up his Canadian citizenship when he went after his peerage. And look at the mess he's in now.
Scrap all awards except for valour, whatever it may be.

13

Political Exile,

Usually in France but in Wales for a week. 16/06/2007 11:35:34

When will this throwback to the Middle Ages come to an end?
I believe that at least a national referendum should be held to decide if the UK public wants to continue with this charade.
However having stated that I must admit to fearing that that with the level of 'celebrity' worship that pervades in the UK there is a high risk that the 'fors' could come out ahead of the 'againsts'.
Would it be regarded as disloyal if the Scottish Parliament decided that such an archaic form of 'private club memberhip' should be regarded as not recognised' in Scotland and at least set an example?

14

Bien E. Bien,

16/06/2007 11:46:51

I am currently looking to hire a sales director for my financial services company; I would give much more credence to an MBA of CFA than I would to an MBE or a CBE.

At least the former 2 imply rigorous vocational study and training.

15

Christopher Crossley,

Wuhan, Hubei, China 16/06/2007 13:08:39

I remember reading in a university alumni magazine that a gentleman in his mid-80s "has become the oldest student to have been awarded an MBE". Does one now receive an MBE just for being a student in advanced age these days?

This puzzled me somewhat until, after reading on, it turned out that he had been awarded an MBA, not an MBE! Still, perhaps he should be awarded both, so he would become Mr. [X], MBE MBA.

The Canadian correspondent in this thread forgot to mention that, though the old British Empire awards are no longer awarded to Canadians (in Canada, anyway), the Order of Canada (O.C.) is the highest civilian order available.

Some (if not all) of the Canadian territories and provinces also award their own equivalent of the order. This is why, for example, the singer Celine Dion is a holder both of the Order of Quebec (O.Q.) and the Order of Canada (O.C.). I believe there is also an Order of Australia (or Australian Order).

Hence, Commonwealth countries like Canada are simply carrying on the tradition, albeit under different and "home-grown" names. The British Empire may be gone, but orders, awards and decorations, "medieval" though they are, such as knighthoods, are very much part of its legacy, even if a lot of people get hot under the collar about the continuation of what many see as an anachronism that ought to have died out when the Empire did.

The same argument could almost be said about honorary degrees from universities. Recipients do not "do" anything specifically to get them; they, like the above awards, are given in recognition of something considered to be in the public good - or at least supposedly so. The recent decision of Edinburgh University to strip Robert Mugabe of his 1982 honorary degree is a reminder, if one were needed, of how flawed the system is.

Indeed, it is interesting to hear that Oleg Gordievsky has been recognised for "services to the security of

16

Beth S,

London 16/06/2007 15:56:33

Surely Peter Sallis plays the voice of *Wallace* in the Wallace and Gromit moves. Gromit doesn't talk.

17

Skatedad,

Home 16/06/2007 16:48:28

Well done Bess.
10/10 for comprehension.

18

Skatedad,

Home 16/06/2007 16:50:10

Sorry, it's my lisp. I should have said Beth S.

19

andrewt,

inverness 16/06/2007 16:53:07

Jobs for the boys . We know a man who got the OBE for planting sitca spruce trees , WHAT,-- SITCA SPRUCE,-- O dear me , some taste!!!!!!

20

Pictus,

Ingleside 16/06/2007 17:45:15

#5, Ubi - "Sir Paris Hilton" . . .Tee! Hee! Hee!

#18, C. Crossley . . . You are odiously underware of the cardinal rule of this page; twit: one may not comment on anything pertaining to any country in which one does not live in.

21

LOWLANDER,

SCOTLAND 16/06/2007 19:14:31

19
WELL SAID FLORIDA,I TOTALLY AGREE.

22

Pictus,

Lake of Shining Waters 16/06/2007 20:03:32

I mean if you don't live in Scotland, you are not a Scot, or even Scotch like (Sir) Harry Lauder. If you don't live in England, you can never have Lymie Disease. If you don't live in Ireland, you might be a Scot 'cos they all moved to Pictland ages ago. If you don't live in Canada, you are simply unlucky. ;-)

23

Cyril,

New Zealand 17/06/2007 06:00:40

In New Zealand and Australia we have the Order of New Zealand and the Order of Australia but we do not give titles to people. Jack here is as good as his master. These two countries are republics in everything except for name. Thank heaven the old British honours system was done away with as we have become independent of Britain and I am ex-British and glad to be away from the snobbery of England.

24

Freethought,

south scotland 17/06/2007 08:49:58

Awards for doing your job? I would agree with some of the sentiments expressed but...there are many people out there doing things for others without thought of recompense and often in difficult situations - how can we recognise them without some sort of award system?

25

Michael J Ramsay,

Pittsburgh, PA, USA 17/06/2007 16:36:33

ZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZZ

26

James England,

17/06/2007 20:20:47

I would like to know how Blair bought his 4 mansion houses. could the cash for peerages have somthing to do with his houses?


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.