Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Wing and prayer fail to save young osprey

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 October 2008
WHEN Deshar the osprey took off on an epic 3,000-mile journey from Scotland to North Africa, he was guided by noth-ing but his instincts.
But those instincts deserted him on the great migration,

and instead of following a direct path across the English Channel the three-month-old bird veer-ed across the Atlantic.

Deshar was tracked by a satellite tag, allowing thousands of bird-watchers to follow his journey, willing him on to safety.

But after flying for 2,000 miles the exhausted bird gave up the fight and is believed to have ditched into the sea, with the tag registering

zero speed and negative altitude.

Deshar was one of three osprey chicks born at Loch Garten this year.

One of his siblings died at birth but the remaining chick, his sister Nethy, has taken an almost perfect route towards North Africa and was last night flying over France.

Richard Thaxton, manager of the RSPB Loch Garten Visitor Centre in the Highlands, where the chicks were born, said it was incredibly sad that Deshar, who was named after a local primary school, had died.

"The satellite data showed, unknown to him of course, that he was heading for the Azores, but he missed the islands and continued on out into mid-Atlantic," he said. "They plunge into the water to catch fish and then take off again; but eventually he ran out of fuel and simply couldn't keep flying."

James Reynolds, spokesman for RSPB Scotland, said: "It shows the perils of migration. This is the most difficult part of their lives.

"They have to make this journey based on instinct, rather than experience, and it is very perilous."

Mr Thaxton described the public outpouring of grief on an RSPB website tracking the bird's progress, which has been visited by 35,000 people, as "phenomenal".

"This has just meant so much to so many people," he said.

He said it was impossible to know why Deshar took the wrong route, and how his sister knew which way to go.

But it was not the first time Deshar had gone in the wrong direction. Shortly after starting the migration from Strathspey on 21 August he headed 70 miles out into the North Sea instead of going south towards England, before realising his mistake and turning back.

Mr Thaxton said possibly it had something to do with Deshar being the younger of the two siblings.

Not only was he born second, but he took his first real flight a day after Nethy, and also set off on the long migration after his sister.

It is the first time ospreys have been tracked on their migration, and scientists hope to learn more about what happens during the journey.

If Nethy makes it to North Africa she will spend about three years there, on what Mr Thaxton called "an extended gap year", before returning to Scotland to breed.



Wings and prayers: Lines on the demise of a so-brave feathered friend

TRIBUTES have been posted on the RSPB's website – www.rspb.org.uk/wildlife/tracking/lochgartenospreys/index.asp – which has given daily updates about the progress of the birds. Here are a few of their messages:

Oh no! poor Deshar i really cant see the keyboard with tears rolling down …what an impact that little bird has had on us.

Milliec

So so sorry – he gave it a bloody good shot poor thing – I hate nature sometimes cos its so cruel – you just feel so helpless – he taught us a lot though and a lot of people out there now know an awful lot more about ospreys because of this fantastic little family – everything crossed for Nethy.

Wild Freckle

We all hoped for a miracle from Deshar but sadly it was not to be. I will always remember him with fondness.

Col

I didn't have much hope and said my goodbyes to his picture on my computer last night and prayed for a quick parting. The tears won't stop and my toast is very soggy this morning – we will miss you little fellow – you had a big heart. Good luck, Nethy – we are all with you.

Heather K

I'm devastated, what a little battler he was flying till the last. So sad we were all so wanting him to succeed. Hope Nethy makes it ok and comes back to raise her own chicks. These birds are so precious.

gsnowey

It does bring home what a dangerous and chancy thing migration is and what an amazing thing it is that many birds migrate successfully.

mozziecat

I've been following the chicks from the US and this is terrible news. My wife and I feel so sad.

GaryS




Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 02 October 2008 1:12 AM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Birds of prey
 
1

,

02/10/2008 00:20:30
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

jerrymanders,

02/10/2008 00:55:57
....meanwhile a spokeperson for Save the Fish Campaign said that they were delighted with the news....
3

Randomly Blocked Poster, ,

02/10/2008 07:08:09
Stressed out before takeoff and carrying extra luggage. Good plan.
4

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 02/10/2008 07:42:25
Mr MacSprog...its been clearly shown that the same "sad" people you refer to are the ones who also give millions to human charities....

nothing wrong with a bit of empathy for struggling nature..
5

Kate,

Zurich 02/10/2008 07:59:53
#1 Jock, right and wrong!

Yes, it's a very sad story about a bird, but this is a very special, very rare bird, which was making its first attempt at a mammoth journey. This was a bird, which was almost extinct in Scotland until these "weirdos" as you so callously call them, dedicated themselves to improving the lot of rare species such as this.

These are also the type of people who dig deep financialy, physically and emotionally to help those less well off, hungry, in need and so on.

Show a little compassion, you'll be surprised that you will actually feel better and certainly more human for it!
6

Boy Wonder,

02/10/2008 08:06:16
Shame about the bird ... but that's life! And death! Get a grip ... and a little perspective, people!
7

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 02/10/2008 08:34:24
This story is both the wrong way round and premature. So far the surviving chick's passage across France is a sign of the bird beating the odds that Nature has stacked against it. But these are early days and it must still run the gauntlet of trigger-happy French and Italian "sports"men - and that is one peril that can and should be better controlled.

It's worth remembering that the Scottish Ospreys are not part of some RSPB Disney-esque re-introduction experiment but are native species that re-settled of their own accord and whilst we should accept losses (such as Deshar - which, btw, is the name of the settlement where Boat of Garten's primary school is located) through natural occurances, we are entitled to feel outraged at the slaughter that still goes on in southern Europe.
8

AJ Fife,

02/10/2008 09:14:09
Go on Boy Wonder, give it your best shot!

How about something along the lines of Kennoway Fried Osprey?
9

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/10/2008 09:37:25
I haven't looked at the RSPB website about this, so do not know if the following general explanation, (which is my understanding of a suggestion by Roy Dennis), has been made there: (I haven't followed the journey of "Deshar", so don't know if this explanation might apply in this instance)

Since ospreys became extinct, due to persecution, in the UK, the present UK population has arisen from ospreys from Scandinavia. Ospreys from Scandinavia may safely take an initially more westerly path in their migration than an osprey starting from Scotland, since if they do so they would hit the British isles. The direction of migration is genetically determined (the parent birds do not guide the young in any way), and thus it appears possible that the problem with the present Scottish born ospreys is that their genetic programming for migration is not quite right. Older birds learn from their mistakes that it is better to head in a more easterly direction when they leave Scotland, so as to fly over mainland Britain on their journey south.

If this is the case, then it is an illustration of the importance of local provenance in animal populations: subtle differences in behaviour of populations from different locations that it is important to try to conserve. Not all animals (or plants) are equal and provenance is important.

It will presumably take many years before the more "head west young osprey" genes are ruthlessly removed from the present Scottish population, before they know better to fly more southerly.
10

,

02/10/2008 09:51:33
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

Jacqueline Hyde ,

On the shelf 02/10/2008 10:16:20
#12
While it's true that there were no records of ospreys in Scotland between (I think) 1911 and the mid-fifties, they returned to Loch Garten of their own accord. I have no doubt that the RSPB has been up to its usual tinkering-with-nature tricks and imported a few from Scandinavia but the majority of birds in this country are Scottich born and bred - I mean Scottish hatched and bred! However some Scottish birds have been resettled in other parts of the UK in line with the RSPB's grotesque experiments. The loss of this chick is no more than an unfortunate act of nature and, for once, the RSPB is probably blameless.
12

Steve Evans,

Malta 02/10/2008 10:37:30
He was probably trying to divert itself from the dreadful bird massacres over the Maltese Islands, a real cancer, just read the Daily Telegraph and Guardian of yesturday.Something needs to be done here.A buoycot of tourism would be a good start.
13

Saoghal Beag,

02/10/2008 11:13:37
#7 Dave, let's get this in proportion. it's not enough to fly them first class flights, they need a specially converted plane with a pool stockled with trout so they don't get stressed or bored through the flight. not much to ask for such a rare and special bird and will prevent potential fires as RSPB member cry onto their electrical euquipment.
14

nhy,

scotland 02/10/2008 11:22:23
has this bird death not just secured the halt of bad genetics progressing in the species and saved future generations?
15

TimW1234,

Ottawa, Canada 02/10/2008 11:37:53
#7 Dave from Barra

Now, Dave, you are just being silly.

Those birdbrains from the RSPB have their priorities skewed.

I shall put myself into 7 days of semi-state mourning, festoon my residence with oodles of black bombazine, and ROAST A DUCK in memoriam.
16

Slioch,

Scottish Highlands 02/10/2008 11:40:04
#14 Jacqueline Hyde

The recolonisation of Scotland by ospreys was not caused by human reintroductions, but happened naturally. But where do you think the ospreys that recolonised Scotland came from originally? Ie. What is their provenance?

They largely resulted from birds that had been bred in Scandinavia but then stopped off to bread in Scotland on their return north after spending their first c. three years in Africa. Thus, they are of Scandinavian provenance. If some had come from elsewhere, Germany for example, then they would still have the genetic trait that would say "flying west is safe", so the above argument #12 still applies. It is only British bred ospreys that need to be careful not to fly west when they migrate.
17

yockel,

02/10/2008 11:59:43
#8 Kate Ospreys aren't rare, there are tons of them just, not many in Scotland. The Weirdows dedicate themselves to interfering and being smug. If they had any feeling for the birds they would not net them, count, them ring them, load them up with electronics and generally mess them about. Oh it's for the good of the birds, no it's not it's for the grant money and the lifesyle. If the birds wanted to live in Scotland they would. They don't because there is better habitat elsewhere. Ask the puffins.
18

,

02/10/2008 13:32:06
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
19

Partan,

Fife 02/10/2008 13:45:54
It is indeed one bird among many, although I suspect that some of the more emotional postings in this article have been selected to make a good story.
I've never understood the argument that showing concern for one issue automatically made you incapable of caring about anything else. In my experience, it's the kind of view advanced by the mean spirited. You know, the kind of folk who wont give to charity because "It will probably all just go abroad/pay their staff/get spent on big office premises" etc.

For anyone interested in the tracking of the ospreys and other birds -
http://www.roydennis.org/osprey.htm
20

Decent,

02/10/2008 14:10:59
It is blatantly obvious what went wrong here. It was the male species who got lost - he obviously didn't want to ask for directions.
21

Saoghal Beag,

02/10/2008 14:48:57
decent, maybe he believed what his sister told him when she read the map for him.
22

Decent,

02/10/2008 15:02:09
Yeah - it just shows you Saoghai - they're trying to blame it on the fact that he was the youngest but it's definatly the sex. His sister made it safely across to France. Why did he want to go to the Azores? Too much ambition - not enough brains.
23

Saoghal Beag,

02/10/2008 15:45:09
25 decent, nah his sister read the map and said turn left, he didn't pay attention to the wing she was pointing with though, poor lad believed her every word.
24

fred bear,

02/10/2008 17:19:37
All this "Scandinavian genes caused it to fly south west" is surely so much drivel. The creatures fly south for some winter sun; the quickest way to this is south wherever you start from. #17 nhy is surely right, it was a bad genetic variation causing its navigation to be out of whack. It now can't breed and spread its lack of spatial awareness to future generations. One for Darwin.
25

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/10/2008 18:02:41
There are some errors in this article or else someone has been telling porkies! Ospreys have been tracked on migration from the UK before now and at least one is known to have perished in a similar manner. The salmon and trout fishermen are probably using mobile phone masts to send out radio waves to confuse the birds. Send large donations to the RSPB so they can investigate the matter!
26

lodger,

Highland 02/10/2008 20:14:22
Ospreys - rare birds???
They are as common as muck in Canada and if you go to Barbados, you will see plenty of them along the beaches - fishing within 30 yards of you white you knock back your rum punch.
Get a sence of proportion you lot of bird brains!
This bird was wrong in the head and unfit for purpose - end of story - end of Deshar!
27

lodger,

Highland 02/10/2008 20:19:29
The RSPB should set up an appeal for kitting out all migrating birds with sat nav equipment. What a load of cash they could extract from gullible folk for that one!
28

danbob,

02/10/2008 21:53:10
32# Funny, except that there's probably an element of truth in that.
29

PointOf View,

Stirling Bridge! 03/10/2008 00:53:17
Mean while back at the ranch!!! Hard working people lose there homes, and can’t fly to a warmer country, There savings and pensions are depreciated due to liebour lies, the children, parents and elderly can eat of heat! Whilst (rich) shareholders of energy companies grow FAT!

The conservative lie (Channel 4 last night) line up the average hard working citizen with lies of moral judgement, an election campaign financed by, yet again, dodgy contributions from “dinner with Cameron at a cost of £50,000, access to the possible priminister nice if you can afford it! So who attends, guess what the seriously rich, who pay little or no taxes, or at least meagre amounts. So here is too many more years of hardship, but hey! Let’s ensure the Osprey chick survives. Something’s got to give but will it be in time? Yet again the Liebour Scotsman tries to redirect the public’s attention from the most important issues. Deserve all we get!!!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.