Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Poisoners put eagles at risk of decline in spite of ideal habitat

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 02 July 2008
SCOTLAND'S iconic bird of prey, the golden eagle, is at risk from illegal poisonings that prevent it becoming established in regions where it should be able to thrive, researchers have found.
Their report shows that numbers of the bird are stable in only three out of 16 regions in Scotland.

Even though many parts of the country have an ideal habitat for the majestic creature, populations are at risk of spiralling into rapid decline.
They are struggling most in regions dominated by grouse moors, where there is evidence they are being poisoned with illegal bait.

Professor Des Thompson, policy and advice manager at Scottish Natural Heritage, which commissioned the report, said the estimated 440 pairs of golden eagle in Scotland would start to plummet unless swift action was taken.

He said there was a dearth of older birds because so many were being poisoned.

"If this pattern continues the population will nosedive because young golden eagles don't breed as successfully as older birds," he said.

"It's a bit like being in a rural area and looking at some of the schools. There are still kids playing in the schools but there are none to come through after them to keep them populated."

The Scotsman has a Stop Them Now campaign to help catch those responsible for killing birds of prey and other wildlife.

The study, A conservation framework for golden eagles, found that in the central and eastern Highlands fewer than half of known golden eagle territories were occupied.

In the Cairngorm mountains, as few as 10 per cent of young eagles may survive long enough to breed.

Prof Thompson said: "I think if this pattern of persecution continues then we will see some further areas being abandoned by golden eagles and that really is bleak.

"The key thing is we try to focus on areas that should be productive for golden eagles.

"We need to concentrate attention there to make sure they are left alone and can produce young."

The environment minister, Michael Russell, said he wanted SNH, the police and land managers to stamp out persecutions. He said: "The golden eagle is a magnificent bird of prey and a key species for Scotland and I find this evidence of its decline deeply disturbing."

Douglas McAdam, chief executive of the Scottish Rural Property and Business Association, said: "Where there's illegal killing of birds of prey of any kind that has to stop. That's a must."

IN NUMBERS

440
Estimated pairs of golden eagles in Scotland.

0
Golden eagles anywhere else in the UK.

3
Regions, out of 16, in Scotland where golden eagle numbers are stable.

86
Vacant golden eagle territories in the central and eastern Highlands.

10
per cent of Cairngorm eagles that survive to breed.

50
Birds of prey known to have been poisoned last year.



Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 01 July 2008 11:41 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Birds of prey
 
1

Schot,

02/07/2008 04:15:21
Grouse moor keepers have been poisoning raptors for at least a hundred years. I remember two prosecutions but I remember hundreds of poisonings.

Does Scotland want grouse bred for rich foriegners to shoot at, or do we want natural Scottish wildlife like owls and eagles - because we can't have both.
2

yockel,

02/07/2008 08:22:48
So is SNH saying that in the Cairngorms National Park area 90 per cent of Golden Eagles are poisoned or do they just not like all that public access.
3

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 10:48:17
Methinks some people are being rather conservative with the truth, or at least the full story. How many former eagle territories are vacant due to forestry planting on high ground? A great many, one behind my house! Planting is still encroaching higher and higher in Argyll. How many eagles have vacated or been unsuccessful in breeding in Argyll since a windfarm appeared in the vicinity of their territory? At least one. How many eagle territories are involved in the recently approved granting of permission for the construction of a windfarm opposite Lochawe village (again in Argyll)? If I remember correctly it is four pairs! Which is probably the most productive area in Scotland for breeding golden eagles? Argyll! Which area of Scotland used to produce record bags of grouse until sheep wrecked the heather moors? Argyll! Which moorlands produce by far the greatest numbers of upland breeding waders which are under great threat on other moorlands? GROUSE MOORS! Take the easy way out, put the blame for your failings to control the public, forestry and sheep onto the shoulders of the true guardians of upland biodiversity. I'm neither land-owner or keeper, but I can recognise a quango cover-up when I see one! Come back Countryside Commission for Scotland and Nature Conservancy Council, your guidance is needed!!!!
4

ohrats,

Scotland 02/07/2008 11:59:53
dido-bendigo #5 is just spouting the usual nonesense you hear from the keepers. Does anyone seriously believe gamekeepers are the "guardians of upland biodiversity"? I've never met anyone who thinks this. These people have only one single solitary purpose - to maximise the number of grouse (etc.) so that they can be shot for fun, and to do this they need to control everything that might prey on grouse. Absolutely nothing else matters. Take a look at googleearth and be horrified by the vast swathes of uplands that are burnt just to improve grouse habitat - its another national scandal.
Actually, I always thought SNH was too friendly with the land owners, and was way too reluctant to criticise them. For SNH to openly criticise landowners (and their keepers) is a big step. With all this information on eagles perhaps its time to name and shame the landowners where eagles are doing so badly? And hey, why not wave the nationalist flag a bit and ask - "are any of these landowners Scottish?"
5

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 02/07/2008 12:28:40
Agree fully with ohrats..

What makes this report so telling is that the authors have looked at all the other possible explanations for the declines in golden eagles in central and east Scotland.....from wind farms to forestry to sheep grazing...and clearly concluded that the real villain is grouse moor "managers"...

the totally artificial habitat known as managed grouse moor was conceived and spread at a time when the killing of all predators was not only legal but being encouraged by all. Now we recognise the value of these birds and animals to the countryside as a whole, surely its time to stop this ludicrous failed experiment and ban driven grouse shooting.After all the landowners and their "servants" are continually telling us you cant run a grouse moor without killing birds of prey...so whats the obvious and democratic answer?....do away with these killing fields.

It is surely not beyond the wit of man to come up with a better use for these scottish hills which will retain wildlife, which can be viewed and enjoyed by the scottish people and tourists alike??
6

yockel,

02/07/2008 13:32:14
#4 Nomada if your able, read the comment, then you read the article.
"In the Cairngorm mountains, as few as 10 per cent of young eagles may survive long enough to breed"
i.e. 90 percent do not survive long enough to breed in the Cairngorms. Fair enough, "As few as" & "may," bit vague perhaps they are not sure.
Its the Eagles that do not like disturbance. Maybe they just don't understand the message Liebour was sending out in the Land Reform (Scotland) Act.
7

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 02/07/2008 14:42:05
I'm with Dido-Bendigo on this one.
The eagles that don't get poisoned will probably get minced by wind turbines.
As for the burning of moors, this is done in stages which is good for a whole variety of wildlife.
I don't see what the fuss is over a few alleged poisonings when the Government, SNH and the RSPB have licensed wind turbine operators to kill dozen's of eagles as well as countless other species of birds.
8

Schot,

02/07/2008 15:28:23
Really ? Do you have any evidence of dozens of eagles called by windturbines ? Cos I'd like to see a link to that, just to prove you aren't just spraffin'. In return I'll link to an article that says "50 birds of prey known to have been poisoned last year."

See above.

9

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 18:08:18
#9 nabodycan

Thanks for you support but I do not agree with the disgraceful practice of laying poisoned baits for anything other than rats and mice in controlled conditions.
10

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 18:15:13
# Schot

I'm sorry to see that you have not trawled the web to find lots of information and evidence on raptors being killed by wind-turbines. Try looking up red kite kills in Wales and Austria over the last six years. I suppose that nine white tailed sea eagles killed in eleven months is not exactly dozens, but who is that pedantic! I'm not going to do the work for you, it's all out there. Just remember - "There is no man so blind as one who will not see"!
11

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 18:26:18
#7 ignorant townie?

Those completely artificial grouse moors are just bursting with biodiversity. Ask the RSPB! They are supporting the highest production of upland waders in the UK! The un-managed moors are becoming deserts for these endangered species, ask the RSPB about theirs!
Not only that but they produce millions of pounds in revenue every year (money an independent Scotland will surely need!) They also support a great many jobs, including student holiday jobs as beaters. Would you send them to the scrap heap, just so a few romanticists can listen to the crows fighting over the last upland curlew chick?!
12

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 18:35:30
Strange how the report concentrates on the grouse producing areas of Scotland and does not consider the Western hill country where so many developers are clamouring to put wind-farms! Perhaps the SNH surveyors didn't get wet weather clothing supplied? But I'm forgetting! The developers employ their own experts to survey sites and make sure that there are no raptors there! Don't they?
13

Schot,

02/07/2008 19:25:30
And I'm sorry to see that you have not trawled the web to find one single link to back up your claim. Sheer distraction.
14

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 02/07/2008 20:02:25
11 Dido, my remark about poisoning was tongue in cheek, I agree with you on rats and mice - that is all I ever poison. I am quite happy to shoot every fox that comes near however! Wait for squeals from the fox loving townies !!!
Schot - you are not looking very hard, how about Altamont pass in the states which has killed thousands, how about Smola which is killing sea eagles.
There is a rather good website on this by a chap called Mark Duchamp, I think it may be called "Iberica 2000" or something like that. Try every EIA that has been written for windfarms all over the west and north west scotland to see how many birds they admit they are going to kill. You really are blind or simply do not want to see.
15

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 02/07/2008 20:28:31
Schot - Try this, you will even see pictures if eagles etc killed by turbines http://www.iberica2000.org/Es/Articulo.asp?Id=1875
16

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 21:36:18
# 16 nabodican

I've been trying to get through to these windy-blow characters for the last seven years regarding bird kills. Are they thick or what?! I've also been trying to get through to the anti's for the last forty or so years, they definitely are in 'heat shield up' mode! No chance of penetrating that dome!

Mark Duchamp had a lot of info on the 'Views of Scotland' website, he also had info on 'Save the Eagles' if I remember correctly? I was in contact with him on occasion when we successfully fought off one wind-farm plan. Thank's for putting up the web-address for Schot, I couldn't be bothered to go through my files. Will you be at the Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust's Fair at Scone Palace, Perth, this Fri, Sat, Sun?

The Scottish Countryside Alliance web-site is carrying some useful press reports at the moment. (Just in case there are any other viewers having a look! Marketing, that is what it is all about! The RSPB are experts at it!). I wonder if there will be another eagle 'discovered' poisoned on another grouse moor on the 11th of August, This year?
17

nabodican,

Rural Scotland 02/07/2008 21:57:39
Hi Dido, unfortunately I am not at home at the moment therefore will be unable to get there.
It sounds as though we may have a few common friends/aquaintances through "save the eagles" "Views of Scotland" etc - no more names off course.

Best wishes and keep up the fight.
18

dido-bendigo,

Scotland 02/07/2008 22:10:27
#19 nabodican

Kindest regards to yourself also. I'm always finding that it is true countryside lovers who defend conservationist principles, support the biodiversity of the natural scene, and really understand what life is all about. All without insulting the opposition to their faces as well! We all really ought to be sitting in parliament telling the 'numpties' how it should be! Alas! Most of us wouldn't have the brass neck to do it! Very sad!
19

Schot,

03/07/2008 00:01:16
"I've been trying to get through to these windy-blow characters for the last seven years regarding bird kills. Are they thick or what?"

You mean you have been spraffin this nonsense for seven years, and you still can't link to any eagle deaths in Scotland caused by turbines.

You have hijacked a report about genuine raptor deaths caused by poisoning and ruined it with speculative nonsense about what may kill them in future. Your platitudes are showing.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.