Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Bird of prey poisoning map of shame published

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 12 January 2009
A MAP showing birds of prey poisoning hotspots in Scotland is published today as part of a new drive to stamp out the killings.
The Scottish Government-backed move was hailed by conservationists for providing the first picture of the scale of the crime and the extent to which it was backed by landowners.

Ministers said it marked a "significant step forward" because the p
oisoning of birds of prey "had often been a source of contention between conservationists and land managers".

The map locates 88 incidents in which raptors were poisoned over the past five years, stretching from the Borders to the Western Isles.

The greatest single concentration was 12 incidents on the Clydesdale/Nithsdale border in the south west. The RSPB recorded a red kite poisoned at Wanlockhead in 2007 and five buzzards poisoned at Leadhills in 2006-7 alone.

There were five incidents around Granton-on-Spey in the Highlands and five on the border between Midlothian and the Scottish Borders. More than one bird was killed in some incidents. A table of bird deaths has also been published, which shows 132 birds of prey were poisoned over the five-year period.

These peaked at 34 in 2006 and fell to 16 last year, but were lower prior to 2004.

Deaths in 2008 include the first sea eagle poisoned for five years, which was found in Angus, and 13 buzzards, which make up the largest number of cases as Scotland's most common bird of prey.

The map was devised after a shake-up of the Partnership for Action against Wildlife Crime in Scotland, which includes the main interest groups. Members agreed independently verified data would enable them to better jointly tackle the issue. The poisoning figures were produced by the Scottish Government's science and advice for Scottish agriculture division.



The Scottish Rural Property and Business Association, which represents landowners, said the map marked a potential watershed in tackling the issue.

Douglas McAdam, its chief executive, said: "With the publication of this report, we move to a position where we are looking at official government verified facts, rather than unofficial reports, where often incidents that might not be illegal are captured in the reported persecution statistics.

"I hope this report marks a turning point where we are all focused on making progress to eliminate all forms of wildlife crime, and on finding resolution to this complex problem."



RSPB Scotland admitted there was still "much to do" in tackling bird of prey poisoning, but said ministers giving their seal of approval to the map was a significant step forward.

Duncan Orr-Ewing, its head of species and land management, said: "Illegal poisoning is an indiscriminate and despicable activity that continues to cause serious damage to bird of prey populations in Scotland.

"We will work hard with responsible land managers, the police and the Scottish Government to resolve this problem."

The map shows poisoning incidents spread across all but western Scotland, north of Glasgow and the far north.



RSPB Scotland said this was because they were not major game rearing or grouse shooting areas, where fears of predatory action by raptors have been linked with poisonings. However, the group believes there may be many unreported cases because poisoned birds are never found.

Environment Minister Michael Russell said: "It is appalling that our birds of prey are still faced with persecution. I applaud those involved for working together on this important issue and hope their efforts will result in a safer Scotland for our birds of prey."

However, The Scotsman's Stop Them Now campaign revealed last month there had been only 26 convictions for crimes against birds of prey in the past decade.





Page 1 of 1

 
1

Bobh,

st augustine 12/01/2009 05:34:05
The penalty obviously is not harsh enough. Put some teeth in the law.
http://www.pbase.com/tsiya
http://smg.photobucket.com/albums/v244/tsiya/
http://cabbagehammock.blogspot.com/
2

Andyfromedinburgh,

12/01/2009 06:41:13
I support moves to link accountibility to the landowners too. This is apolluter pays principle...

Also I am quite sure if this material is publicised in tourist board circles reputations will be damaged as other economic interests will be affected.

Collective accountibility....

3

gus1940,

Edinburgh 12/01/2009 08:01:49
Jail the poisoner and the landowner and ban them from holdinga firearms licenses for life.

More effectively impose a ban on all field sports on the landowner's property for 10 years.
4

westcider,

Isle of Lewis 12/01/2009 08:03:56
I never saw a buzzard when I was a lad, the first ones I saw were in the middle East. Now there is a buzzard on a fence post down every road in the country as they are primarily carrion eaters and thats where they pick up their food nowadays. They seem to co-exist quite happily with our other wildlife so their persecution was obviously unnecessary.
5

Nailhead401,

sitebased 12/01/2009 08:50:24
Wanlockhead and Leadhills, have you been there?
i hear dualing banjos in the background....
nuff said.
6

drunken proffet,

Tassy 12/01/2009 08:50:30
I know nothing about birds of prey. Apart from maybe they are territorial. It would seem that if the map was produced locally to a better scale and the locals could witness those areas where birds thrived and those areas that were devoid of that type of birdlife, you do not need to be a rocket scientist to figure out where the problems lie. We have the same thing in Tasmania, one season you have eagles and other raptors and the next they are in short supply. In this case they are not targetting the birds but the animals that prey on the young trees in the plantations. Same result, different method.
7

Farmernot,

12/01/2009 09:07:31
16 Cases in 2008....Wow......knife crime cases 100's.........road deaths 1000's..........soldiers illegally killed in Afghanistan/Iraq by GB/USA 100's.....can we please get some proper perspective on this Hootsman reporters......you have an article a week on this for goodness sake !!!!
8

The Jannie,

Out there, watching 12/01/2009 09:27:56
The map is too vague. Detailed site information would tell more of a story then some of these scum might get their just desserts.
9

yockel,

12/01/2009 09:33:36
#7 Absolutely, especially when you deduct the the 13 buzzards, not to mention the dubious Mull Sea Eagle found in Angus.
10

Partan,

Fife 12/01/2009 10:06:33
What's "dubious" about the sea eagle, then, Yockel?
Eagles released in Fife have turned up on the West coast, Eagles from the West coast may well, and probably do, visit the East.
If you look at the satellite maps on the Highland Wildlife Foundation site, you'll see the kind of distances an eagle can cover in a day. Bit of an eye opener.
11

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 12/01/2009 11:29:54
So....Over 30 years of such maps produced annually by the RSPB [in the 1970s a "map of shame" was published showing pole trappings on estates all over the UK]and this one is put forward as "the first picture of the scale of the crime..."!!..Even The Scotsman has published such maps before!?

The criminals involved here go up to a very high level in our society and have managed up to now to prevent any serious use of "official" resources to prosecute these crimes - that includes members of the Police and Justiciary.

But now theyve got their own reports on the problem...what does it show?...exactly what the RSPB has been banging on about for decades!...wake up naive shooters and gamekeeper supporters...there is no conspiracy against you...these crimes are widespread and the criminals are amongst you...and its up to you to stop it...not rely on Charities to show you the way...

12

ignorant townie?,

Scotland 12/01/2009 11:37:24
#8 The Jannie...quite right...all cases positively analysed by the governments own scientists [which is all the ones on this map...and all the previous RSPB annual reports] should give as exact a location as possible..

Why?...because most of the poisons used such as carbofuran, are deadly poisons to humans as well as wildlife...wouldnt you like to know if your friendly neighbourhood gamekeeper was putting down deadly poison near your livestock, pets or even children?

This is a health and safety issue and a damn serious one.

So why in recent years has SASA, the governments analysts stopped printing locations in its reports and put in Regions instead?...because of pressure from the landowners [SRBPA, formerly SLF]!

Time to get that changed, politicians....
13

Urban Guerrilla,

Edinburgh 12/01/2009 12:37:40
Yawn.
14

Upbeat,

12/01/2009 12:56:10
When the locations of currently active landfill and those of brownfield -former heavy industrial - sites are tabulated onto this map, then the correlations will become clearer.
15

criochan,

Lochailort 12/01/2009 14:27:48
#14: Not too hot on geography, are we? Not too many landfill sites, even fewer brownfield heavy-industrial sites in the Cairngorms ..... and even if there were, what's your point?
16

Ronda,

New York State 12/01/2009 16:03:44
In the U.S. we keep track of the economic importance of watching wildlife. http://library.fws.gov/nat_survey2006_economics.pdf There is an economic importance to watching birds in Scotland. The number of people who flock to see the osprey at Boat of Garten is a good example. Scotland as a whole and VisitScotland as the country's tourism promoter need to do a better job of capitalizing on the economic importance of watching birds of prey. Once that importance is well established and documented people will be less inclined to have them killed. In the U.S. wildlife watching is outstripping the blood sports.
17

sam the god,

12/01/2009 17:06:29
Any good recipes for them?
18

Geomac 1,

Scotland 12/01/2009 17:21:12
Does Scotland have a MAP of murders/homicides of humans?
If not, why not? It seems to me that we are overly attentive of so called wild life crime - which, by the way, seems to be reliant solely on data from the RSPB - and is not supported by proven cases
19

Endemoniada,

12/01/2009 19:06:10
#18 "so called wildlife crime"
#9 "dubious Mull Sea Eagle"

Waken up people!

The Sea Eagle was found by a landowner, collected by Tayside police and tested by a government lab. It had been poisoned (crime) by a chemical banned since 2001 (crime). A follow-up search found 30+ poison baits (crime) placed in open countryside laced with the same poison (crime). You don't get much more clear-cut than that.

How is this reliant on RSPB data? Perhaps we should be asking why it has taken so long for these proven, confirmed crimes, published online by the Scottish Agricultural Science Agency for years, to actually be acknowledged by Mr McAdam and others...
20

,

12/01/2009 19:52:44
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
21

Kenny's Conscience,

An Eyrie Outside Inverness 12/01/2009 23:05:44
Haul them up before the Beak!!!!

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.