Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

Drink Driving, Don't Risk It!

Believers in beavers win right to bring back rodents after 400 years

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 26 May 2008
PRIZED for their fur, hunted for their meat and sought after for the supposed medicinal qualities of their tails, beavers were always going to struggle to survive.
But now, 400 years after they were hunted to extinction in Britain, the rodents are to be re-introduced to Scotland. Up to four families of European beavers will soon be making their homes in Argyll, after Michael Russell, the environment minister, approved a trial scheme.

The move follows a long-fought campaign by wildlife enthusiasts to bring back an animal which they say will contribute greatly to biodiversity. And, if successful, it could see other extinct species return to Scotland.

The Scottish Wildlife Trust's chief executive, Simon Milne, said: "This is more than just bringing back a single lost species. It's about rebuilding our depleted wildlife communities and re-invigorating the natural dynamics of Scotland's wetland and woodland habitats – to the advantage of existing as well as homecoming species."

The trust and the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland joined forces to apply for a licence under the Wildlife and Countryside Act to release beavers into the wild in Scotland.

It is planned that the beavers will be captured this autumn in Norway and placed in quarantine for six months. Three or four families will then be released at lochs in Knapdale, Argyll, next spring.

Mr Russell said it was "an exciting development for wildlife enthusiasts all over Scotland and beyond".

He said: "They are charismatic, resourceful little mammals and I fully expect their reappearance in Knapdale to draw tourists from around the British Isles – and even further afield.

"Other parts of Europe, with a similar landscape to Scotland, have re-introduced beavers and evidence has shown that they can also have positive ecological benefits, such as creating and maintaining a habitat hospitable to other species."

He said Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) would monitor the progress of the new residents over the next five years before a wider re- introduction programme was considered. The impact the beavers have on the environment and economy will also have a major influence on the final decision.

"For now, though, we should enjoy the sight of beavers roaming wild in Scotland for the first time in more than 400 years," said Mr Russell.

Professor Colin Galbraith, the director of policy and advice for SNH, said no other beaver re- introduction project in Europe had gone through such a thorough process of preparation, assessment and examination.

The Scottish Beavers Network – an Inverness-shire based group made up of landowners, ecologists, tourist operators and wildlife enthusiasts – have tirelessly routed for the re-emergence of the beaver.

The group claims that, since the extinction of the animals, there has been a major gap in the ecosystem. It is hoped that now the nocturnal creatures will provide slower-moving water through their dams and lodges, creating new opportunities for aquatic plants to thrive.

David Windmill, chief executive of the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland, said the granting of the licence was "a strong and visible sign of the Scottish Government's commitment to carrying out conservation in Scotland and rebuilding our depleted biodiversity".

He said if the scheme was successful, other species could be introduced in Scotland in the future.

However, the Scottish Rural Property and Business Association which represents landowners, is worried that beavers could block salmon runs with their dams or undermine waterways with their burrows.

"This does not have universal support," said the association's Highland manager, Drew MacFarlane Slack. "If it does get the go-ahead, I would be concerned if any of our concerns are not addressed in the licence."

Master builder who sustains wildlife and wetlands

When did beavers become extinct in Scotland?

They died out 400 years ago, following a sustained period of hunting for their fur and a chemical in their tails – castoreum – which was believed to have medicinal properties and a derivative of which is used in asprin today.

Were they targeted for anything else?

In some areas, beaver meat was an important part of the diet and Roman Catholics were permitted to eat meat from the tail and paws as a substitute for fish on a Friday.

When did we start to think about re-introducing them?

There have been various attempts over the years, but Scottish Natural Heritage launched a major study which reported back in 1997.

When did the groundwork begin for the latest attempt?

In January 2007, the Species Action Framework was launched by Scottish National Heritage. It provides a strategic approach to species management. In July, Michael Russell MSP, the environment minister, said he was interested in bringing beavers back.

Then what happened?

The Scottish Wildlife Trust and the Royal Zoological Society of Scotland joined forces to consider an application for a licence for a new trial in Knapdale and, with support from the Mammals Trust UK, launched a local consultation in the Mid-Argyll area last October-November.

Why would we want them back?

They are known as a keystone species because their presence helps other wildlife and improves habitats. By building dams they create ponds and wetlands that attract other species such as frogs, toads, voles, birds and fish.

Any other benefits?

They help to improve water quality and manage local flooding by creating their own flood defences. In the woodlands they help to stimulate new growth.

Have any other countries re-introduced them?

From the 1920s, successful reintroductions have taken place in 24 European countries.

And have they benefited economically?

Guided beaver safaris operate in Brittany, Belgium, Denmark, Poland and Sweden where guests pay to view.

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 25 May 2008 11:30 PM
  • Source: The Scotsman
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Beavers
 
1

,

26/05/2008 00:21:39
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
2

Jock Tamson,

Scotland, Caledonia, Alba 26/05/2008 00:25:10
Lest anyone complain about my post at 1, let me qualify it by comparing the go forth and multiply attitude of the animal freaks to the human dynamic they wish to deny the people of Scotland.
3

,

26/05/2008 01:23:40
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
4

Guga II,

Rockall 26/05/2008 02:09:18
As long as these nutters that want to re-introduce things like wolves and bears don't get their way.

There are too many people, usually foreigners, that want to treat the remoter areas of Scotland as some sort of wildlife sanctuary; and others that want to treat it as some sort of playpark for the idle rich. They conveniently forget about the people that live here. We are neither a park nor a dumping ground.

5

,

26/05/2008 02:10:49
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
6

Guga II,

Rockall 26/05/2008 02:10:51
As long as these nutters that want to re-introduce things like wolves and bears don't get their way.

There are too many people, usually foreigners, that want to treat the remoter areas of Scotland as some sort of wildlife sanctuary; and others that want to treat it as some sort of playpark for the idle rich. They conveniently forget about the people that live here. We are neither a park nor a dumping ground.

7

Guga II,

Rockall 26/05/2008 02:12:55
Sorry about the repetition people, the Hootsmon site was sticking.
8

indune1,

Canada 26/05/2008 02:28:53


British beaver? No, sorry folks, we have all the beaver you need.

Four or two-legged!
9

,

26/05/2008 03:25:04
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
10

Animal Doc ,

USA 26/05/2008 03:34:44
I think this is great news! Studies in other countries of the reintroduction of the beaver have shown great promise for the regeneration of ecosystems and the benefit of eco-tourism i.e. tourism based on reintroduced animals, though my prime interest personally is the ecological benefits. Caution of course must be used but I attended a presentation/debate not that long ago and while I was initially sceptical, believing that bad things could happen ecologically as the landscape now is very different than when they roamed before they were extinct, I was convinced that reintroduction of beavers will be handled cautiously and monitored closely and there are plans in place if unforessen effects occur. I am aware some may be of the opinion it is great for me to sit in the USA where I emigrated to this year and spout opinions about Scotland, but I am sincere in that I would want the same if I was living in Scotland still.
11

Beth Boyle,

NY 26/05/2008 04:19:59
More beaver and less sheep. Sheep distroy everything in their path. I raise sheep but there are too many in the highlands chomping down all the new trees and heather.
12

Glenn in Alberta,

Innisfail 26/05/2008 06:15:01
The "charismatic, resourceful little mammals" are better described as destructive wee rodents! They cut down entire trees to digest a few of the top branches.Having eliminated all available trees they move on to a section of the stream with more trees to destroy. Rather reminiscent of clear-cutting on the Amazon. They dam up streams and cause erosion of the banks. The stream running through my farmland is plagued by these critters. A trout fishing association pays trappers to get rid of them. No deciduous trees near a stream are safe from their depredations. You will rue their re-introduction to Scotland.
13

Prester John,

Pots_n_Pans 26/05/2008 07:41:04
Well actually, I hope to see the reintroduction of moose, lynx in my lifetime.

Guga may not like it but I would happily see wolf and bear reintroduced, not least to predate on the deer which are another factor holding back Scotland's natural ecosystems. They're no threat to people. Try walking in forest and mountains in eastern Europe and see how unaware you are of their presence. Even grizzlies and spirit bears in North America (never mind black and brown bears) tend to avoid people.
14

,

26/05/2008 08:14:02
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
15

Tweedmouth,

Coldstream 26/05/2008 08:29:32
Fascinating that not one of the offical wildlife apparatchiks mentions 'Beaver Fever' - more correctly known as Giardia - the cause of voilent dysentery and the pollution of public water supplies.Giardia is an amoeba-like parasite that is spread through rivers, lochs, ponds and public reservoirs by the faeces of infected animals: beavers, foxes, badgers etc. However, since beavers spend 99% of their time in the water and defecate in the water - they are the perfect vehicle for transmission. One single infected animal can spread millions of Giardia parasites through a river system - and it is very, very infectious.

The prasite can survive boiling in water, freezing in ice and even chlorination. Symptoms of violent diarrhoea and agonising abdominal cramps may take 2 weeks to appear and it can take 6-8 weeks to cure. Produces serious weakness and weight loss.
http://www.outdoorplaces.com/Features/Backcountry/giardia/giardia.html

"Generally a person suffering from Giardiasis will show symptoms ten to twenty-one days after ingestion, but this time period can be shorter or longer. Infection can last from four days to four weeks, or even longer. Symptoms include oily, foul smelling diarrhea, a feeling of weakness and being run down, abdominal cramps, unexplained weight loss and nausea. More severe cases can bring on anorexia, vomiting and fever."

So - get ready people - youir public water supplies, Loch Lomond, The Tweed and the Tay are soon to be bringing you regular outbreaks of a very serious illness. And once it is here - it's here FOREVER - it has never been eradicated from anywhere it has become established. Still - thousands of cases of children rushed to hospital with life-threatening diarrhoea, weight loss and agonising pain - its a small price to pay so the 'quangocracy' can indulge their fantasies.
16

Saoghal Beag,

26/05/2008 08:32:40
Guga with no natural predators what is going to happen, either the call goes up for wolves or they have toi cull the cute little dam builders. that should raise a few moans.

It is one thing to reintrodyce raptors at the top of the food chain, but herbivores with no -predators is just purte insanity.
17

voltaire's janny,

26/05/2008 08:41:16
Prester John. You make no sense. Wolves & bears re-introduced in Scotland would surely thrive. Not where misty eyed romantics want them, of course but around commercial herds of deer and sheep and when they get a bit old, perhaps the odd toddler or family pet would be menu items too.
18

The Man With No Clue,

26/05/2008 08:44:58
One does so hate to be pedantic but if the beaver was hunted to extinction 400 years ago why does the caption under the photograph (gratuitous beaver shot if ever there was one!) say it was nearly half a century since they became extinct?

Maybe they became extinct, then 350 years later popped up for a day or two before being driven to suicide because they were sick of all the 'beaver' jokes.

Either that or someone doesnt know the difference between their centuries and their millenia!
19

Bard,

26/05/2008 09:07:00
`So - get ready people - youir public water supplies, Loch Lomond, The Tweed and the Tay are soon to be bringing you regular outbreaks of a very serious illness. And once it is here - it's here FOREVER.`


So how come it isnt in Scotland now, if here FOREVER?
20

katmur,

26/05/2008 09:33:20
#2 and #4
I absolutely agree - the SNH and others are turning into a bloody mafia - i'm sure if they had their way the Highlands and Islands would be evacuated of most of its people, with a few token 'natives' left over for the tourists to take pictures of. Instead of trying to sustain and encourage human populations these fools complain about every development opportunity. That's not to say they're wrong in all cases but at some point humans need to be put before the wildlife that's reclaimed what used to be living communities.
21

haggis 10,

26/05/2008 09:50:10
# 14 Where did you get the recipe Sounds delicious
22

Gunn,

NW UK 26/05/2008 11:21:09
Squirrels, flat worms, Parakeets and various geese and ducks, all of which significantly compete with truly native species. Just because beavers have been successfully introduced in other countries doesn't mean they will be here because OUR eco-systems are different from theirs. And besides, who says they have been successful? Has this been independently verified by qualified folk other than those who wanted to re-introduce them in the first place?
23

Douglas,

Bathgate 26/05/2008 11:31:42
It seems like someone's beavering away in the back office deleting innocent postings. Says a lot for what's going on in the minds of the censorious.
Who knows what the reaction will be when we move on to pu$$y-willow cultivation. :o)
24

Douglas,

Bathgate 26/05/2008 11:33:05
Yes, that's right folks, pu$$y is a banned word in Hootsmonia.
25

Guthrie,

Edinburgh 26/05/2008 11:43:54
IF there is a problem with the beavers, they'll just shot or trapped, as before. This is a very low risk thing to do.
26

Stirling Sentinel,

Stirling 26/05/2008 11:54:18
I wonder if mink traps will deal with them should they spread to the Central Belt.
27

katmur,

26/05/2008 12:49:01
#24
I'm guessing you work for SNH since you seem a wee bit oversensitive about them, at least they keep a few folk in a job eh? If you read the comment with a calm and clear head you'll see i was agreeing in principle to some of the previous posts and making a general point that one conservation group or another object to every suggested development in the H&I, and you'll also see I said these objections were not always without justification. Another example is a recent housing development stalled because 'Buglife Scotland' found some rare ants in the area
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/scotland/highlands_and_islands/7243505.stm
In other words after years of population loss and lack of housing the people of the Highlands are reduced to beneath the status of ants.
28

Bunty,

Holton St Mary 26/05/2008 13:02:50
Haggis 23 ref 14. Darn it! Recipe got taken, must be cooking up a meal in the back office, best start practicing my badger and venison stew! Bet they are tasty little critters!!
29

stoatsnest,

Ham 26/05/2008 13:08:03
Reintroducing 'lost' species has worked very well in South Africa, where sheep have over grazed the natural habitat, turning parts of the country into a waste land.
If the thing has been studied properly, it is likely the beavers will benefit Scotland.
I don't understand why some correspondents think beaver friendly is people unfriendly.
The planet would be a barren place without animals.
30

katmur,

26/05/2008 13:16:52
#32 - So by the general drift of your argument then you have no concern of the social consequences of any public body - the Government or the conservationists - providing barriers to the development of areas lacking in resources and housing?
31

stoatsnest,

Ham 26/05/2008 13:35:32
I'm afraid that is a poor argument. The areas where beavers are going is hardly going to be suitable for housing.
Sorry to harp on about the South African example, but their housing and social problems are much worse than those of Scotland.
The reintroduction of animals in their old habitats has not only rejuvenated the land, but provided employment and income from tourism, both internally and from overseas.
I appreciate Scotland has suffered abuse from the land owning classes, e.g. the Highland clearances, but one does have to look at this rationally, and the experience of other countries is a good benchmark.
32

katmur,

26/05/2008 13:56:56
#35 I'm sorry stoatsnest but you're getting confused with the development of the argument - i didn't suggest housing was to be built on rivers in place of the beavers dens - the point was a more general one about convervation v development led on from previous points, and they are coming into conflict. Any wildlife that can help local areas is a good thing, but more and more development proposals are being halted by conservation groups - so the ideal of both living in harmony is a good one but it's not the reality.
33

Saoghal Beag,

26/05/2008 13:57:57
Guthrie, but shooting fluffy cute beasties is not going popular with certain sectors of the population.
34

katmur,

26/05/2008 14:02:04
#36 - "Second, there are plenty areas in the Highlands and elsewhere that are zoned for housing, and will accommodate housing, without any significant harm to wildlife. Third, even where there may be significant harm to wildlife, mitigation can often minimise or remove the harm"
You're contradicting yourself there - couldn't you make up your mind?
By the way there's no need to be so rude -
35

stoatsnest,

Ham 26/05/2008 14:07:43
Thank you katmur.
I'm not for conservation if it's not applied with common sense, but a few beavers seem pretty harmless to me.
I appreciate there is a wider argument, and am not familiar with the local details.
Where I work-Croydon-development went mad in the sixties and is responsible for all sorts of social problems.
36

MadMax,

26/05/2008 14:20:40
I am happy the beavers are back and surprised no one has put up this link:
http://www.naute.com/stories/dam.phtml

Fact or fiction I dont know but all the same highly amusing.
37

Grouse,

Thunder Bay 26/05/2008 14:38:07
For now, though, we should enjoy the sight of beavers roaming wild in Scotland for the first time in more than 400 years," said Mr Russell.
Sorry Mr. Russel........beaver don't roam.

I see nothing wrong with introducing beaver as long as they are kept under control and supervised and kept well away from farming land,roads,highways and railways. [ not that I care if they get killed but they create havoc with the local drainage systems....culverts etc.

eg.....C.P. Rail lost 400m of mainline due to a burst beaver dam....and CP actively control beaver activity near their tracks.....repair costs were substantial.

A pair of beaver can 'knock-off' 400 trees a year and they only eat hardwoods....poplar, birch etc.....no soft woods like fir etc.

To repeat if they are well supervised.....no problem !
If the thrill wears off and supervision stops a bunch of beaver can build a dam big enough to take out a small village......or the West Highland Way...especially with the amount of rain you get.
Bob

38

peter e,

missouri 26/05/2008 14:48:13
What a bunch of wimps, afraid of a few beavers. We have mountain lions returning to Missouri, an no one is shaking in their boots.
39

sonofhamish,

edinburgh 26/05/2008 15:01:32
A great idea, especially when the species was hunted to extinction by man.

As for Jock Tamson and Guga.. you guys really are pathetic.
40

katmur,

26/05/2008 15:13:09
#44 You are absolutely contradicting yourself - the whole point of my argument is that the needs of people are being undermined, and reduced to below that, of wildlife. In your post at #36 you make exactly the point i am trying to make - wildlife considerations come first, while also claiming a negative response to my question at #34. Read it carefuly and that's clearly what you imply. By the way your posts were rude from the beggining - too many like you on forums who think they can speak like that just because they're not face to face. But thank you for helping me prove my point.

I think it's absolutely contemptible that in one of the most sparsely populated areas of the EU people are held hostage by wildlife.
41

yockel,

26/05/2008 16:13:17
It's time the entire UK was shut down and turned into a nature reserve. Labour could lease off a few bits to the Yanks for some secret prisons and a radar station or two to cover the much reduced running costs.
42

Ronda,

New York State 26/05/2008 16:24:39
According to this article, the beavers are being "re-introduce." My impression was that beavers were native to Scotland. If that's correct, then they can't be re-introduced but re-established. And someone should let the writers at The Scotsman know that. If I'm incorrect and beavers aren't native to Scotland, I would be opposed to them being re-introduced.
43

Saoghal Beag,

26/05/2008 17:06:52
still remains good money wasted that could be better spent on what ecosystems we have that are under threat.
44

Bachus,

26/05/2008 18:16:44
William Whalen,of Linksview House, Tolbooth Wynd, Leith.
Is a scumbag who robs pensioners at knife point.
Watch yer back Willie we know where you live.
45

Bachus,

26/05/2008 18:32:35
Sorry wrong story, I though I was in the one about the MP getting mugged.
46

Bachus,

26/05/2008 18:33:24
But the beavers better what out for William Whalen, of Linksview House, Tolbooth Wynd, Leith.
47

peter e,

missouri 26/05/2008 18:57:32
I can't believe it! That the re-introduction shoud be greeted with anything but joy, I don't understand. 22 years ago, Missouri reintroduced river otters. Now they are a bit of a bother, causing damage to some ponds but they are trapped when bothersome. Over all, its fun living in a park. We have Deer, turkey, mink, raccoon and other wild life that visit our home almost daily.
We have not been eaten yet. Live on the wild side, take a chance!
48

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 26/05/2008 20:12:42
Beavers are no use! - they are vegetarian ! ... By releasing wolves and bears into several known troublesome 'estates' I should think it would have a very positive effect on the NED population by keeping their numbers down.

Sadly I think they are thinking of releasing large carnivores in the wrong type of estate usually where there are no NED's to feed on at all ! Poor things may starve !

52. I did think it was hilarious that a Labour MP got mugged I have barely stopped laughing - the irony is so sweet !! .... they have been in denial for years and have taken away all form of discipline form parents and schools - so they are just getting their just deserts - I just wish it would happen a bit more often so they could get a real taste of the society they and the disgusting PC brigade have created.

49

zigzag,

Canada 26/05/2008 21:26:56
The beaver is a cuddly warm soft fluffy bit of animal that needs to be regularly spoilt and pamopered with jewelry, flowers and night out on the town.
Canad has many such creatures and they are especially welcome on cold winter nights when it is a pleasure to seek snug comfort in a beaver's den. Cosy cosy cosy.
50

indune1,

Canada 26/05/2008 22:05:45

Zigzag! LOL! However, remember beavers are experts at clogging things up (dams) and they eat hard-wood
(get my drift(wood)?), so one has to be careful not to be become too cosy and snug (smug?).

From a fellow Canadian beaver admirer.
51

Voldemort,

Edinburgh 26/05/2008 22:16:11
57/58 -- I suppose someone had to .... still .... quite funny though !
52

Kipling,

26/05/2008 23:21:12
#41. LOL.
Perhaps they could be hired out to the water companies down south, who seem to lose more water than the reservoirs contain.
53

Conan the Librarian™,

26/05/2008 23:22:04
58
You'll like this then Dunnie;

http://1149.ca/Gallery/wide-open-beaver.jpg
54

Angus,

Alexandria 26/05/2008 23:54:10
I think this is yet another example of wildlife being exploited for tourism - Mike Russel admitted it would be a tourist draw in a radio programme this morning.

It's the same with squirrels. Red squirrels are an attraction so they're killing the greys in a grossly unfair campaign against them.

In the present economic climate, popular tourism is likely to suffer its greatest setback for decades and could be a thing of the past in not too many years to come. Perhaps the Minister for the Environment should recognise the damage tourism is doing to the planet and concentrate of protection rather than encouraging exploitation of the environment.


55

indune1,

Canada 27/05/2008 00:40:55

61 - How are you Conan?

One of our iconic symbols has seem to have got several people into a tail-spin, or a tail-smack.


56

Monty Dog,

Montana 27/05/2008 05:50:47
Bring back the furry little devils by all means. Use
them to take over from the eco-loonies, global warming
nuts, and other al gore types.
57

,

28/05/2008 00:46:25
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
58

zigzag,

Canada 28/05/2008 01:24:41
Hey Indune1 in Canada.
One time I was camping up in the Muskokas and to my surprise, during the night when I was asleep, I was awoken by a warm beaver sitting on my face. TO my horror, I think it had had a meal of fish before visiting me. No worries though;oncew one licks it the fishy smell is no longer an issue. I was relieved to find out that although this made me woody, I was luck to not get chewed out right away. Once we (the beaver that is) built a trusting realtionship, it was woody woody all the way...you would need a dam to contain me.
59

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:07:47
Lots of comments on " Beavers"
Glad to see testerone is up...
What's the date of the Gala Day in Galashiels
this year?
Many years ago I worked for the Border Standard in Gala & always enjoyed covering the Gala Day
60

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:08:57
My Pleasure
61

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:12:38
I would be pleased to talk to any one of your journalists. As a photographer I met a Scotsman photographer & used to meet him in the Pub just behind the Scotsman. He was my Hero & to drink with a big time paper guy was an honor
62

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:13:47
I would be pleased to talk to any one of your journalists. As a photographer I met a Scotsman photographer & used to meet him in the Pub just behind the Scotsman. He was my Hero & to drink with a big time paper guy was an honor
63

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:24:10
#2 Jock Tamson usti live doon below us in Gala
he was a grand singer... wid ye bne a relation?
Sorry if I'm off the subject.
64

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:28:36
#11 away we EWE
65

Galalean,

Mission 28/05/2008 04:34:37
How come the usual lobbyists are not on today?
No money in Beavers I guess...

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.