Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement


Former Roller ready to sue ex-bandmates over royalties claims

Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date:
23 March 2007
FORMER Bay City Rollers singer Nobby Clark has threatened to sue his old bandmates if a legal claim they have launched against Arista Records is successful.
Today, in the latest instalment of an increasingly bitter row over the missing millions generated by the band's commercial success, he hit out at his one-time friends.

Six former band members have launched a writ in the US for unpaid royalties for hits such as Bye Bye Baby appearing on compilation albums.

But Mr Clark, 56, claims he was the creative force behind their chart-topping success and should receive a substantial share.

He is even prepared to take legal action to scupper the bid of the six former Rollers, including other original members bassist Alan Longmuir and his brother, drummer Derek, and Les McKeown, Mr Clark's replacement in the band.

Mr Clark said: "I've appointed a lawyer to look into this. It's my intention to make sure those guys don't get a penny.

"Or I will wait until they come back to this country and then I will sue every single one of them the minute they step off the plane.

"I started the band with the brothers when I was 15 years old. I created the name. The whole image was created by the three of us."

Mr Clark left the band in 1973, but it was not until eight years ago that he fell out with the other former members, when they launched their first bid for unpaid royalties.

Believing he had been frozen out of the claim Mr Clark launched a rival writ, but neither side ever reached the courtroom.

However, this week the six former members filed a lawsuit in the US District Court in New York, claiming Arista Records had failed to pay them huge sums in royalties over 25 years.

"There is no money they could ever get that they could say I am not entitled to," said Mr Clark.

"Every single album has my performances on it, all except for the ones in the latter stages of the band which did not sell well.

"There were six or seven hit singles that have been released on compilation albums all around the world, and I've not received a single penny.

"I wrote Because I Love You, which sold 800,000 copies."

Mr Clark, who now lives in Holyrood Road and relaunched his singing career in 2002, added: "As far as I know all the royalties were paid to Bay City Music Publishing, in London.

"Now I read the Rollers are suing Arista for fortunes. I just wish the whole story would go away but, be assured, I will not go away."

Mr McKeown has confirmed he was involved in a lawsuit but he said that they had all agreed not to comment on the case. Their lawyer was unavailable to comment on Mr Clark's claims.

The band says Arista has continued to profit as a result of selling albums, merchandise and rights to commercials, films and even telephone ringtones.

In the lawsuit, the Rollers claim a contract states Arista must account for and pay royalties to them twice a year, with obligations dating back to the 1970s.

The lawsuit alleges a payment of £133,000 in September 1997 was the only one made to the band, well short of the millions the musicians believe they are owed.

Joshua Krumholtz, of US law firm Holland and Knight, the lead counsel for the group, said on Tuesday: "Through this lawsuit, we intend to secure the royalties owed to the Rollers for the huge commercial success of their music. They have waited long enough."

Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 23 March 2007 1:30 PM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Bay City Rollers
 
1

Paula Voltaire,

23/03/2007 12:09:14

Come on Rollers, give a little love to Nobby. Ok sure he was yesterdays hero and possible a summer love sensation but we all remember (sha la la la) him.

So fans I urge you to turn on the radio, keep on dancing (especially on Saturday Night) sing a lo0ng a shang a lang with Nobby or it will be bye bye baby to one of Edinburghs finest.

2

Billy_o,

23/03/2007 12:14:43

It's a crime!

3

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 23/03/2007 12:22:28

Can't say I have ever heard of him.

4

,

23/03/2007 12:24:17
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 470335, Article id was mapped to record!
5

,

23/03/2007 12:25:58
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason: Scotsman Import, Original comment id: 470340, Article id was mapped to record!
6

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 23/03/2007 12:40:53

IMPERSONATING ME

7

Paul Voltaire,

www.paulvoltaire.spaces.live.com 23/03/2007 12:41:11

u CHEEKY MAN

8

alex paterson,

embra 23/03/2007 12:50:29

#5 Whats an anagram,

9

Paula Voltaire,

23/03/2007 13:17:34

I'll have you know I'm all woman!!

10

petrol head,

Edinburgh 23/03/2007 13:33:58

I was more into Slade, T-Rex and Sweet when the Rollers were about.

11

elayne,

fife(formerly edinburgh) 23/03/2007 13:44:46

bay city rollers were keech!all that crap about romance and stuff,i preferred the runaways,bad girl rock rules!

12

Chip Stencil II,

Swan City 23/03/2007 14:45:04

Each member of the Bay City Rollers should be lined up against a wall and shot one by one for crimes against music, with that fat, drug dealing, junkie, sex offender of a manager going first.

13

funkadeefunk,

23/03/2007 15:02:48

I actually met Nobby thru work about ten years ago and he really is the world's bitterest, angriest man.
This story comes a no surprise at all.

14

Dave Hedgehog,

23/03/2007 15:07:04

You can talk about copying people Paul Voltaire. I’ve just read a film review on the Daily Mirror website that you have plagiarised verbatim and plonked on your blog as your own. What a sad little man you are.

http://blogs.mirror.co.uk/entertainment/davidedwards

15

alex paterson,

embra 23/03/2007 15:07:24

Paul or Paula, Rise to vote sir,Able was i ere i saw elba.

16

James2122,

23/03/2007 15:10:35

If Nobby wrote some of the music and played in most succesfull records and most importantly was an active participant form the start until when these songs were created then of course he should get a share of the money. Arista has taken the p out of the rollers who it seems to me had very little business savvy. Why should they not get what should be theirs? they;ll no doubt waste it on crap anyway.

17

Embra boy,

23/03/2007 15:47:51

Surely they'd be better uniting to pursue royalties, and not scrapping amongst themselves.

Like the palindromes btw Alex!

These Voltaires are breeding fast aren't they? Paul, Paula, and now the contrary-opinionated alter-ego Veto. (Wasn't he one of the Corleones too?)

18

Filled Rolls,

Definitely Back in 1973 Now 23/03/2007 15:48:51

"Now I read the Rollers are suing Arista for fortunes. I just wish the whole story would go away but, be assured, I will not go away."

Why would you not go away if the story goes away. Surely you've got your own way?

I think Nobby has been eating some of the blue potatoes that lie around the floor of Davie Paton's tattie shed in Cockenzie.

(Only true Rollers fans will get this).

19

Chip Stencil II,

Swan City 23/03/2007 15:57:27

#16 Great exposé on the fraud that is Paul Voltaire Dave.
He's plagiarised myself more than a few times on these very pages - most recently hijacking my swan campaign. What a pathetic charlatan he is.

20

Peter M,

Spain 23/03/2007 16:13:49

Haha! Well done #16 Dave Hedgehog!

The idiot has not even spotted the Mirror's typo, 'Cate Blachett' so he's probably not even read it himself!

Voltaire you ****

21

Embra boy,

23/03/2007 16:15:05

I hope you're not talkingabout my swan campaign!

22

Cora,

US 23/03/2007 16:29:09

Nobby Clark quit of his own accord before the band became insanely famous. He had nothing to do with their longterm popularity - it was the classic five that the girlies were mad over, and they looked a lot different after his tenure. The classic incarnation toured the world and worked exhaustively to make it to the top, but Nobby had left long before. I don't know that Nobby wrote any of the songs, either, which is a major part of the lawsuit. He certainly could get a little something out of the deal, but to say that the success was all about him is ridiculous. Maybe he should pony up some money for attorney's fees with the group and stop being so bitter if he wants to share in the profits.

23

Chip Stencil II,

Swan City 23/03/2007 16:29:16

#24 Embra Boy -
I was campaigning against swans when you were neck high to a cygnet, pal.

24

Cora,

US 23/03/2007 16:32:35

Oh wait, sorry, he wrote one song. Out of eight albums and a bunch of hit singles then, and a zillion compilations with non-Nobby performances since. So I guess he should get all the money.

25

Embra boy,

23/03/2007 16:33:52

#26. I know what you mean, they're very snooty birds, all that swanning around they do. Ugly ducklings the lot of them.

26

john 1,

23/03/2007 17:15:50

They quickly forgot about their young local fans in Cockenzie where they used practice and Jockie C. who fed them. They got what they deserved.

27

Jakey Rowling,

23/03/2007 17:44:36

Hope he gets the money, by the look of the picture he needs to get that subsidence sorted pretty quickly.

28

Tam O' Shanter,

23/03/2007 18:22:19

Nobby Clark just looks sad.

29

Chuck.U.Farley,

23/03/2007 19:49:50

#10
Ask Tam Patton

30

Woody47,

23/03/2007 21:42:39

I think Nobby has been overdoing the dreaming. It was only AFTER he left that the band started hitting the charts. Where he thinks he was on albums that were selliong millions is beyond comprehension. It was 1974 to 1976 when the rollers were huige and he left in 1973 - DO THE ARITHEMETIC NOBBY - just another bitter person trying to jump on the wagon. Why didn't he try and do something in the 70's OR 80's or 90's?

31

Biker,

Ayr 23/03/2007 22:01:47

Sorry Woody, as Noddy was an integral part from the begining he should be given some of the loot. From the very begining these guys were being ripped off and dumped on by Fat Tam. Perhaps the missing millions should be investigated by the police and Mr Paton be the first for investigation.
Keep it up Nobby.... Good lad!!!

32

Biker,

Ayr 23/03/2007 22:02:08

oops Nobby

33

Douglas,

Bathgate 23/03/2007 22:02:41

22,24,26,28: Is there a bit of swanupmanship going on here?
Don't get a cob on.

34

King Banana,

23/03/2007 23:00:20

Can I have a swan campaign or have they all been taken?

35

Yane,

Kata Tjuta 24/03/2007 00:14:14

Hope he can pay those lawyers he's hired -- or he'll be crosser than ever.

36

Yane,

Kata Tjuta 24/03/2007 03:23:39

#39 Fear not! He commented on the tories building mair jails -- great revolutionaries that they are --

37

Lorraine McLellan {nee HOGG},

Perth Western Australia 24/03/2007 08:46:30

I can remember Nobby and the rest of the boys in the band gardening and doing things for Mrs Clark,when we lived next door in Drumbrae drive.its such a shame to see how things have turned out

38

siusaidh,

24/03/2007 18:22:01

I can see, how Nobby perhaps should get some of the money, but by far not the biggest amount and fighting against the rest of the group, won't do any of them any good...so either join the rest of them fairly ,Nobby or just wait and shut up untill the rest of them manage to win something of their royalties back and then try to negotiate with them a fair amount.
Actually none of the songs, which Nobby was involved with were put onto compilations, so his royalties would be negligiable compared to the rest of them.
Talking of which.......why is number 6 Duncan and not Ian or Pat...?

39

Cora,

US 25/03/2007 03:24:40

siusaidh, Duncan wrote or co-wrote a lot of the material on the later albums after Les left the group - he was actually with the post-Les Rollers for several years. I think Pat had a co-author credit on one song, don't know that Ian had any. They were only with the band a few months each and probably weren't signators on any of the contracts with Arista that are at the heart of the litigation.


 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.