Help Sitemap Home Skip Navigation Contact Us Disability Statement

 
 
Friday, 5th September 2008

Premium Article !

Your account has been frozen. For your available options click the below button.

Options

Premium Article !

To read this article in full you must have registered and have a Premium Content Subscription with the Edinburgh Evening News site.

Subscribe

Registered Article !

To read this article in full you must be registered with the site.

Activity course offers ray of hope



Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image
Click on thumbnail to view image

Published Date: 15 May 2008
YOU could almost hear the blood pressure rising and the splutters of outrage. No doubt there was also some cracked china as teacups were forcefully rattled back into their saucers in sheer indignation at the news that the Government has launched a scheme which will see juvenile delinquents sent on adventure courses in an attempt to try and help them sort their lives out.
The 12-month pilot project will involve ten young people from Lothian and the Borders who have been identified as those most likely to be placed in secure accommodation or custody because of their offending behaviour.

It's the kind of story that
prompts a knee-jerk reaction of the worst kind about the "scum children" of "scum parents", and "why should they get to go and enjoy themselves at my expense?" or "what about my law-abiding kids who I have to pay for if they want to go on such a course?"

But that's just the point isn't it? Thankfully for the majority of parents in Edinburgh, if they want to provide a similar opportunity for their children then they probably can just about afford to do it – and more importantly know how to access these experiences in the first place.

Undoubtedly, the parents of the teenagers who are being targeted in this new move either couldn't afford to give their kids such a chance or wouldn't even think about it due to their own lack of motivation or belief that their lives can be improved.

Who knows from where such a lack of hope or determination to succeed stems, but should that mean that children in such families – children who can yet be saved from a life of moving from secure accommodation to prison – should just be written off?

Surely as a civilised society we should be doing all we can to turn these youngsters into responsible citizens who can give something back to their communities?

Those who suffer from the offending behaviour of such children – be it vandalism or petty theft – are no doubt at the end of their tethers and have the most right to be annoyed that the perpetrators are not being severely punished. But surely even they can understand how giving a glimpse of light at the end of the tunnel could keep such youngsters on the rails?

And if seven days of hiking in the Scottish countryside and learning how to become self-reliant can in some way help to do that, then the cost – a mere £123,000 – is irrelevant.

Of course, the hard work begins when these kids return to their real lives. These are children who are brought up in situations of real economic poverty. In many cases, their parents are likely to be on benefits and uninterested in encouraging a different life for their kids. Others may have hard-working single parents who, through trying to do their best to keep their head above water, end up failing to be around for their children when they really need them.

Is it any wonder then that coming from such backgrounds, between 70 to 80 per cent of youngsters in custody suffer from some sort of mental health problem? It is shocking that they're under such stress that their mental health is being affected at such a tender age.

These troubled young people seem to lack a sense of self, of hope, and also the social cohesion which would keep them on the respectable side of life.

This is where resources need to be targeted, and this pilot project is just the start. But the parents of these children need to be helped too, through support measures which could at least encourage them to instil some belief in their kids that life does not have to be a relentless round of dole money, dope and detention.

Because the good news is that parental influence is still a major factor in children's lives. Indeed, in one survey, 70 per cent of children said the person they most admired was their mother, while 62 per cent said the person they admired the second was their father.

Of course, it's easy for parents whose children are law-abiding, decent and good, to scoff that such people will never change and it's a waste of money in even attempting to help them. Perhaps they should remember that even children from "good" families can go off the rails. It's not just those on benefits whose marriages disintegrate, or who have issues with drugs and alcohol.

If their own son or daughter were to become such an offender, wouldn't they prefer it if they were offered the chance of a countryside hike rather than a police cell?

Family matters
IN the same week that Hearts ended their worst season in years, it was wonderful to read the recollections of one of the club's legends Bobby Kirk, when the team was in better fettle and actually managed to get its name inscribed on some silverware.

However there was a small omission from the Tynecastle side's triumphs – though not by Kirk as he wasn't playing for the team in the 1954-55 season when they won the Scottish League Cup for the first time.

According to my father, these things matter more the further away the victory gets – and even more so when his brother-in-law, Alex Bain, was playing for the opposing side, Motherwell, that day.

Consider it mentioned.





The full article contains 912 words and appears in Edinburgh Evening News newspaper.
Page 1 of 1

  • Last Updated: 15 May 2008 8:34 AM
  • Source: Edinburgh Evening News
  • Location: Edinburgh
  • Related Topics: Gina Davidson , Youth crime
 
1

allknowing,

15/05/2008 11:45:26
"for their children then they probably can just about afford to do it – and more importantly know how to access these experiences in the first place"

Total tripe!

Just picture this and try and give me a decent response.

Two kids in the playground. One kid, John, is well behaved and follows rules, is polite and never gets in trouble. He is from a poor part of Edinburgh, but his parents have brought him up well, and do their best on their limited budget

The other kid, Andrew, doesnt follow rules, and after a telling off from his teacher, gets up and punches her. He too is from the same estate as John, but his parents couldnt care less where he is , or what he gets up to.

John finds out that ANdrew is going on a holiday for a week, all paid for, and asks himself, why dont I, who is good and do what I am told, get to go away on these trips. Well you know what, I am going to do what Andrew does, as he seems to get what he wants, and do things his own way.

What a great example we are setting children!
2

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

, Newington 15/05/2008 13:25:53
"Surely as a civilised society we should be doing all we can to turn these youngsters into responsible citizens who can give something back to their communities?"

How about nurseries, schools, libraries, parks? The taxpayers pay for them all in the belief that they're there to turn youngsters into productive and law-abiding citizens.

When however they turn into destructive or violent criminals, then it should be their turn to pay, not receive a free holiday as a reward.

If Gina Davidson is so keen, she can pay my share. Please contact the Evening news for where to send my cheque.
3

tomias,

Edinburgh 15/05/2008 13:42:41
Gina I give up- it's been a long time- come on tell us just how old you are.
Ta.
4

The Judge,

15/05/2008 14:36:10
Another tree hugging yogurt knitter.

Ms Davidson imagine your car has been trashed by little Kyle, he is caught by accident by L&B police, he appears in front of the children panel, it's his 34 offense, they arrange for a free adventure holiday to try and encourage him out of crime, leaving you to pick up the bill for the damaged car.

Who's won? Not you thats for sure, you've got a bill for the repairs to your the car, perhaps running into 100's of pounds, you probably won't want to claim from your insurance because of your no claims, so that money comes out of your pocket.

Kyle on the other hand now has 35 convictions for "low level" crime and a free adventure holiday. All he had to do was blame his parent for being poor, turn on the waterworks for five minutes to fool his social worker into thinking he'll change his ways and get the mugs like you and me to pay for it.

How about instead of pandering to the poor we punish the criminals send little Kyle's mum the bill for the damage, if she's not working take it from her benefits, little Kyle won't be out trashing cars at 11pm for much longer.

The Kyle's of this world are laughing at people like you, because they know they can virtually get away with murder and blame it all on their poor background.

5

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

,Newington 15/05/2008 15:49:50
The Judge is correct. Those who can write "Those who suffer from the offending behaviour of such children" are not if fact those who do suffer from the depredations of these budding psychopaths. Mostly folks who write yoghurt-knittings paens like this are happily esconsed in middle-class ghettoes and well insulated from them.

On the other hand, those of us who grew up amongst them know exactly how they regard the addle-pated halfwits who reward crime sprees with free holidays. We also know what it is they do need, and that's castration to stop any further peeing into the gene pool
6

Alfred E. Neuman,

15/05/2008 16:06:27
So, let's sum up this pile of crap article.

Middle class can pay and so should.

Poor criminal from scum-bag parents cannot pay (through willfully lazy scrounging parents) and so should not pay, and neither do without.

Poor law-abiding child from hard-done-by but hard working none the less toilet cleaner single parent family, cannot pay, but should and will do without.

Come on, we can do better than that. Reward the decent with the trappings of a adventure holiday.

Reward the criminal with a punishment and rehalbilitation, such as taking the parents on an urban holiday to view scarred faces, broken fences and so on.
7

Unimpressed one,

15/05/2008 19:09:47
"And if seven days of hiking in the Scottish countryside and learning how to become self-reliant can in some way help to do that, then the cost – a mere £123,000 – is irrelevant."

And people wonder where our society's gone wrong? Birching should be re-introduced.
8

Teofilio Cubillas,

15/05/2008 19:55:49
"then they probably can just about afford to do it – and more importantly know how to access these experiences in the first place."

This is part of the problem - hand-wringing liberals like the author of this bilge treating the underclass like children and wiping their backsides for them at every opportunity. Gina, I just googled 'activity break' - 3,270,000 hits. It's that easy.

Oh, and #4 -how can Kyle have 35 convictions if L+B polis 'accidently' catch him? I'd say they were doing a pretty good job.
9

Alfred E. Neuman,

15/05/2008 20:01:54
How many municipal 5 a-side football pitches does £123,000 buy?

Why benefit the community when you can treat just 10 undeserving souls?

I bet if you asked these lads what would better prevent them from offending, a 7 day holiday in isolation or the chance to play football 365 days a year with the chance to build confidence by showing off physical prowess to the communities nubiles - they would choose a football pitch.

The SNP are barking, the cause of these petty criminals is obvious, they are young alpha males and without a chance to shine out of school they go off the rails.

Municipal sports facilities, it's the only way for everyone who hates the scouts.
10

,

15/05/2008 20:40:43
Comment Removed By Administrator
Reason:
11

A Friend of Fernando Poo,

, Newington Common Sense Society 16/05/2008 03:06:26
Alfred: building them football pitches will just turn them into violent hooligans. Look what happened in Manchester.

Best spend the 123 grand on Chess sets. Nobody ever heard of a Chess Riot.
12

Kevin Connor,

Meadowbank 16/05/2008 11:19:59
Some sense from the EEN at last.
Well done Gina.
13

antifa,

18/05/2008 14:59:20
"Is it any wonder then that coming from such backgrounds, between 70 to 80 per cent of youngsters in custody suffer from some sort of mental health problem?"

If this is true (and I notice the hang-em and flog-em brigade have chosen to ignore this this), that's an appalling testimony to the shape our society is in. Why are our kids being driven mad before they've even had a chance in life?

On the other hand, like the green-inkers above, I'd question whether an adventure holiday is the answer. If these kids have mental problems, they have medical needs: you're not going to fix their problems by teaching them how to put up a tent.

 

Comment on this Story

 

In order to post comments you must Register or Sign In

 
 
 
  

 
 


Sister Newspapers:
Press Complaints Commission

This website and its associated newspaper adheres to the Press Complaints Commission’s Code of Practice. If you have a complaint about editorial content which relates to inaccuracy or intrusion, then contact the Editor by clicking here.

If you remain dissatisfied with the response provided then you can contact the PCC by clicking here.